Hard-to-value intangibles
Example 31 — Sales materially higher than projected — alternative payment structures
Annex II · Example 2 · ¶28–33
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same Phase-II transfer as the previous example. In year 7, audit of years 3–5 reveals sales of 1 500 in years 5 and 6 — vs. a year-0 cap of 1 000. The risk-adjusted revised NPV is 1 300. Is a single year-0 lump-sum adjustment really the right way to fix it?
The parties
Company A
Patent transferor · year-0 lump sum 700year-0 lump sum · adjustment in year 3?
Company S
Achieves sales of 1 500 in years 5–6 vs. projected ceiling of 1 000What happens
- Year 0: Company A transfers Phase II patent rights to Company S for a lump sum of 700 (year-0 cap on sales: 1 000).
- Year 7: Country A tax administration audits years 3–5.
- Audit findings: sales of 1 500 in each of years 5 and 6 — significantly higher than projected.
- Taxpayer cannot demonstrate that the year-0 valuation considered such sales levels, or that they were unforeseeable.
- First market approvals were obtained in year 3.
Analysis
Re-running the year-0 valuation with the higher sales scenario gives 1 300 (vs. the original 700) — so a 600 adjustment. No HtV exemption applies.
What's the best way to implement the 600 adjustment?
OECD analysis · Adjust 600 — consider milestone form
Ex-post outcomes are presumptive evidence that higher sales should have been considered at year 0; the revised year-0 NPV is 1 300 (not the same as a pure ex-post NPV). The tax administration may assess additional profits of 600. Given the size of the revision and the valuation uncertainty, an alternative payment structure — for example, a further payment in year 3 when first market approvals were obtained — may be more consistent with what independent parties would have done. The principles apply whether the audit covers years 0–2, years 3–5, or both.
Key takeaway
Large HtV revisions invite a structural rethink, not just a number. Where independents would have used contingent or milestone payments to cope with valuation uncertainty, that form can be a better way to land the adjustment than a single year-0 reprice.
Related: Chapter VI · Section D.4 (HtV approach) · Paragraph 6.183 (alternative payment structures) · Paragraph 6.192 (use of ex-post evidence)