Hard-to-value intangibles
Example 30 — Phase II patent transfer — earlier sales than projected
Annex II · Example 1 · ¶21–27
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
In year 0, Company A transfers a Phase II pharma compound to Company S for a lump-sum 700, based on projections of sales starting in year 6. On audit in year 4, sales have already started — in year 3. What can the tax administration do, and does the answer change if the gap is small?
The parties
Company A
Patent transferor · Phase II compound · valuation 700 in year 0patent rights · lump sum 700
Company S
Acquires patent · runs Phase III · earlier commercialisation than projectedWhat happens
- Year 0: Company A transfers Phase II patent rights to Company S for a lump sum of 700.
- Pricing assumption: sales would start in year 6 and not exceed 1 000 a year.
- Year 3: commercialisation begins — Phase III completed earlier than projected.
- Years 3–4: sales correspond to those originally projected for years 6 and 7.
- Year 4: Country A tax administration audits years 0–2 and observes the ex-post outcomes.
The questions
A
The taxpayer can't show that the year-0 valuation considered an earlier-sales scenario, or that the early sales were genuinely unforeseeable.
What adjustment can the tax administration make?
OECD analysis · Adjust +300 (year 0)
The tax administration uses the ex-post outcomes as presumptive evidence that the year-0 valuation did not consider earlier sales. The valuation is revised to include the risk-adjusted possibility of earlier sales — assume the year-0 arm's-length price should have been 1 000 rather than 700. The 1 000 is not the same as an NPV based solely on the actual outcome. An adjustment to assess additional profits of 300 in year 0 is appropriate.
B
Same problem with the year-0 valuation — but the revised NPV is only 800 (not 1 000), so the proposed adjustment is 100 (not 300).
Does the HtV adjustment still apply at this smaller size?
OECD analysis · Within 20% → exempt
The tax administration's analysis would lead to a 100 adjustment. However, the exemption in paragraph 6.193(iii) of Chapter VI applies, because the adjustment to the original compensation is within 20% of the compensation determined at the time of the transaction. The HtV approach therefore does not result in an adjustment in this scenario.
Key takeaway
Significant ex-post deviations from the year-0 plan create presumptive evidence that the original valuation was wrong — but the adjustment is to the risk-adjusted year-0 view, not to the realised outcome. The 20% safe harbour caps small revisions.
Related: Chapter VI · Section D.4 (HtV approach) · Paragraph 6.193 (HtV exemptions)