Valuation techniques

Example 29 — DCF from both sides — and the realistic alternatives

Annex I · Example 29 · ¶104–111 · Pervichnyi group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Pervichnyi transfers Product F manufacturing — and the related patents and trademarks — to Company S in low-cost Country Y. DCF gives a seller value of 600, a buyer value of 1 100, and a third realistic alternative (toll-manufacture) at 875. Where does the arm's-length price fall?
Pervichnyi
Parent · developer · seller of IP
IP sale · lump sum (range 875 ↔ 1 100)
Company S
Low-cost manufacturing buyer · receives IP
  1. Pre-year 1: Pervichnyi develops Product F patents and trademarks; manufactures in Country X and supplies arm's-length-priced distribution affiliates worldwide.
  2. Year 1: Pervichnyi sets up Company S in low-cost Country Y to save costs.
  3. Year 1: Pervichnyi sells the Product F patents and trademarks to Company S for a lump sum.
  4. DCF analysis: seller's keeping-as-is residual cash flow has NPV 600; buyer's residual cash flow has NPV 1 100.
  5. Realistic alternative for Pervichnyi: retain IP and use Company S (or alternative supplier) as toll manufacturer in Country Y — NPV 875.

An arm's-length price must work for both the seller and the buyer, given the alternatives each has. The DCF figures are simplified but illustrate the point.

Within what range does the arm's-length price fall?

OECD analysis · Range 875 ↔ 1 100
Pervichnyi would not sell below 600 (continue-as-is) and would not sell below 875, since its realistic alternative is to use a low-cost contract manufacturer while retaining the IP. Company S would not pay more than 1 100. A DCF-based transfer-pricing analysis must consider how independents would take into account cost savings and tax effects in setting the price. The arm's-length price falls between 875 and 1 100.
Key takeaway
DCF asks both sides — and asks each side what else it could realistically do. The arm's-length price lives between the seller's best alternative and the buyer's break-even.

Related: Chapter VI ¶6.153–6.178 (DCF guidance) · Chapter IX (realistic alternatives)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →