Valuation techniques

Example 28 — Aggregate valuation where intangibles cannot be split

Annex I · Example 28 · ¶101–103

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company B sells patents, trademarks, know-how and customer relationships to Company C, and then becomes Company C's contract manufacturer. The group can't reliably segregate the cash flows of the different intangibles. Aggregate or asset-by-asset?
Company A
Parent
group context
Company B
Sells intangibles · becomes contract manufacturer
intangibles · lump-sum
Company C
Acquires intangibles · manages business going forward
  1. For valid business reasons, the group centralises in Company C all intangibles related to business conducted outside Country S.
  2. Company B sells its patents, trademarks, know-how and customer relationships to Company C for a lump sum.
  3. Company C retains Company B as a contract manufacturer of products previously produced and sold by Company B on a full-risk basis.
  4. Company C has personnel and resources required to manage the acquired business and develop the intangibles further.
  5. The group is unable to identify comparable uncontrolled transactions.

There are no comparables. And the group can't reliably separate out the cash flows of each intangible.

Should the intangibles be valued one-by-one or as a bundle?

OECD analysis · Aggregate valuation
Under these circumstances, in determining the arm's-length compensation to be paid by Company C for the intangibles sold by Company B, it may be appropriate to value the transferred intangibles in the aggregate rather than to attempt a valuation on an asset-by-asset basis. This is particularly so when there is a significant difference between the sum of separately valued individual intangibles and the value of the business as a whole.
Key takeaway
When cash flows cannot be reliably split between intangibles, aggregate. Force-allocating across assets adds spurious precision without improving reliability.

Related: Example 27 (cross-check failure) · Chapter VI · Section D.2 (combining intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →