Valuation techniques

Example 27 — Patent valuation cross-checked against the whole business

Annex I · Example 27 · ¶97–100

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company B sells the Product M patent to Company A. Valuation analysis prices the patent at 80; a parallel DCF of the entire Product M business gives 100. After functional returns and value for trademarks and know-how retained by Company B, the 20 gap looks too thin. What does this mean?
Company B
Seller of Product M patent · retains trademarks & know-how
patent sale · valued at 80
Company A
Parent · centralises patent ownership
  1. Company A owns various IP across the group; Company B owns Product M patents, trademarks and know-how.
  2. For sound business reasons related to coordinating patent protection, the group centralises patent ownership at Company A.
  3. Company B sells the Product M patents to Company A for a lump sum.
  4. No comparable uncontrolled transactions are identified; the parties apply valuation techniques.
  5. Patent valuation arrives at NPV of 80 (with adjustments to address material differences vs. industry royalty data).
  6. A DCF of the entire Product M business by Company A arrives at NPV of 100.

Only 20 is left over (100 − 80) to cover both Company B's normal functional returns and the trademarks and know-how it keeps. That looks too thin.

What does this gap tell the analyst?

OECD analysis · Cross-check exposes 80 as unreliable
The 20 gap between the entire-business NPV (100) and the patent NPV (80) appears inadequate to cover routine functional returns for Company B and the value of trademarks and know-how that Company B retains. Further review of the reliability of the 80 patent valuation is called for.
Key takeaway
Cross-check valuation techniques against each other. If the residual after the patent valuation is too thin to cover everything left over, the valuation needs another look.

Related: Chapter VI · valuation techniques · Example 28 (aggregation)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →