Valuation techniques

Example 26 — Acquisition premium licensed to a regional sub

Annex I · Example 26 · ¶92–96 · Osnovni group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Osnovni acquires publicly listed Company S for 160 when the shares were trading at 100. The premium reflects synergies with Osnovni's existing products. Osnovni liquidates Company S and grants Company T (its European/Asian licensee) an exclusive perpetual licence over the acquired IP. What should T pay?
Osnovni
Parent · acquired Company S at 160 vs trading value 100
acquisition + liquidation
Company S (liquidated)
Brings products, IP and workforce
exclusive licence · ?
Company T
European/Asian licensee · receives perpetual licence
  1. Company S is publicly traded at an aggregate value of 100; competing bidders offer 120–130.
  2. Osnovni acquires 100% of Company S for 160; PPA: tangibles 10, intangibles 60, goodwill 90.
  3. Osnovni justifies the 160 by reference to complementarity between its products and Company S's products and pipeline.
  4. Company T is Osnovni's wholly-owned subsidiary that has historically held arm's-length exclusive licences for Europe and Asia.
  5. Osnovni liquidates Company S, then grants Company T an exclusive perpetual licence covering Company S's products in European and Asian markets.

The 60 premium over Company S's trading value comes from synergies — some in European and Asian markets (Company T's territory), some elsewhere.

How much of the premium should Company T pay for in its licence?

OECD analysis · Allocate territory-relevant premium
In pricing the Company S intangibles licensed to Company T, the premium over the original trading value should be considered. To the extent that premium reflects complementarity with Osnovni group products in European and Asian markets, Company T should pay an amount that reflects an appropriate share of that premium. To the extent the premium reflects complementarities outside Company T's markets, it should not be taken into account. The PPA intangible value is not determinative.
Key takeaway
Acquisition premiums map to synergies. When an acquired intangible is sub-licensed to a related party, the part of the premium tied to that party's markets goes with the licence — and the rest does not.

Related: Example 22 (synergy goodwill on transfer) · Section D (transfers of intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →