Valuation techniques

Example 23 — Acquisition then immediate IP migration

Annex I · Example 23 · ¶83–85

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Birincil acquires Company T for 100 — driven mainly by promising technologies and the R&D workforce. Right after closing, Company T transfers all developed and partly developed tech to Company S and switches to contract research for Company S. What did Company S actually get?
Birincil
Acquirer of Company T · 100
share acquisition · 100
Company T
Continues as contract researcher on its old tech
tech transfer + contract research
Company S
Receives Company T technology · funds future R&D
  1. Birincil acquires independent Company T for 100; PPA shows 20 to tangibles & identified intangibles, 80 to goodwill.
  2. The 80 in goodwill reflects partly developed technologies and the potential of Company T's workforce to develop new ones.
  3. Immediately after closing, Company T transfers all developed and partly developed technologies, patents, trade secrets and know-how to Company S.
  4. Company T enters a contract-research agreement with Company S at cost-plus; Company T workforce continues to work exclusively on the transferred technologies and future technologies.
  5. Company S has the personnel and management to direct and control Company T's R&D work.

Company S now controls the research; Company T still houses the people. The 100 Birincil paid is good evidence of total business value.

How should the 80 of accounting goodwill be split between Company S (the IP buyer) and Company T (the people)?

OECD analysis · Specific identification + combined remuneration
It is necessary to identify which intangibles are transferred to Company S and which are retained by Company T. The PPA's allocations are not determinative for transfer-pricing purposes. The 100 paid by Birincil reflects an arm's-length price for the business; that full value should be reflected either in the assets transferred to Company S or in the assets and workforce retained by Company T. Company T should be compensated for its contribution — either through the IP-transfer price or through the post-transaction R&D-services compensation.
Key takeaway
Accounting goodwill is a starting point, not the answer. The transfer-pricing question is: which specific intangibles moved, what stayed behind (including workforce-in-place), and across the two legs together does Company T get the value the independent purchase price implied?

Related: Example 22 (synergy goodwill) · Example 26 (acquisition premium and licensing)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →