Valuation techniques
Example 22 — Goodwill from synergies in an acquisition
Annex I · Example 22 · ¶78–82
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Birincil buys all of Company A — which owns a mining licence (standalone value 20) and a railway licence (standalone value 10) — for 100. Its purchase-price allocation puts 70 of the price into goodwill from the synergy between the two licences. The licences are then transferred to Company S. At what price?
The parties
Birincil
Acquirer · pays 100 for Company Ashare acquisition · 100
Company A
Holder of mining (20) + railway (10) licenceslicence transfer · ?
Company S
Subsidiary · receives the two licencesWhat happens
- Company A holds two government licences: mining (standalone value 20) and railway (standalone value 10).
- Birincil, independent of Company A, acquires 100% of Company A's equity for 100.
- Purchase-price allocation: 20 to mining, 10 to railway, 70 to goodwill (synergies between the licences).
- Immediately after acquisition, Birincil causes Company A to transfer both licences to Company S, a Birincil subsidiary.
Analysis
Birincil paid 100 for the whole company — and that price reflects both licences plus the goodwill from running them together.
What price should Company A charge Company S for the licences?
OECD analysis · Price must include synergy goodwill
Identifying the intangibles transferred with specificity matters. The goodwill associated with the licences must be considered in the transfer to Company S because value generally does not disappear or is not destroyed in an internal restructuring. The arm's-length price should take account of the two licences and the value ascribed to goodwill; the 100 paid by Birincil provides useful information on the combined value of the intangibles.
Key takeaway
Goodwill arising from synergies between transferred intangibles travels with them. An intra-group transfer cannot strip out the synergy value that an independent purchase price included.
Related: Section D (transfers of intangibles) · Example 23 (workforce/goodwill split)