Valuation techniques

Example 22 — Goodwill from synergies in an acquisition

Annex I · Example 22 · ¶78–82

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Birincil buys all of Company A — which owns a mining licence (standalone value 20) and a railway licence (standalone value 10) — for 100. Its purchase-price allocation puts 70 of the price into goodwill from the synergy between the two licences. The licences are then transferred to Company S. At what price?
Birincil
Acquirer · pays 100 for Company A
share acquisition · 100
Company A
Holder of mining (20) + railway (10) licences
licence transfer · ?
Company S
Subsidiary · receives the two licences
  1. Company A holds two government licences: mining (standalone value 20) and railway (standalone value 10).
  2. Birincil, independent of Company A, acquires 100% of Company A's equity for 100.
  3. Purchase-price allocation: 20 to mining, 10 to railway, 70 to goodwill (synergies between the licences).
  4. Immediately after acquisition, Birincil causes Company A to transfer both licences to Company S, a Birincil subsidiary.

Birincil paid 100 for the whole company — and that price reflects both licences plus the goodwill from running them together.

What price should Company A charge Company S for the licences?

OECD analysis · Price must include synergy goodwill
Identifying the intangibles transferred with specificity matters. The goodwill associated with the licences must be considered in the transfer to Company S because value generally does not disappear or is not destroyed in an internal restructuring. The arm's-length price should take account of the two licences and the value ascribed to goodwill; the 100 paid by Birincil provides useful information on the combined value of the intangibles.
Key takeaway
Goodwill arising from synergies between transferred intangibles travels with them. An intra-group transfer cannot strip out the synergy value that an independent purchase price included.

Related: Section D (transfers of intangibles) · Example 23 (workforce/goodwill split)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →