Transfers & services with IP
Example 25 — Services improved by tools — but no IP transfer
Annex I · Example 25 · ¶89–91
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Prathamika lends two of its litigation lawyers to Company S for one specific lawsuit. The lawyers use Prathamika's proprietary document-management software in their work, but Company S receives no right to use the software elsewhere. Is there an intangible transfer?
The parties
Prathamika
Parent · litigation team and proprietary toolslegal services (tool-enabled)
Company S
Receives two lawyers for one matterWhat happens
- Prathamika's internal legal team develops experience in large-scale litigation and proprietary document-management software.
- Company S faces a complex litigation matter similar to those handled by Prathamika.
- Two Prathamika lawyers are made available to Company S to manage documents in the Company S litigation.
- They use Prathamika's document-management software on this matter only; Company S obtains no rights to use the software in other matters or to make it available to its customers.
Analysis
The software is just a tool the lawyers use on this one matter. Company S gets no right to use it elsewhere.
Should this be priced as a service or as a transfer of IP?
OECD analysis · Service fee, no IP transfer
It would not be appropriate to treat Prathamika as having transferred rights in intangibles as part of the service arrangement. However, the fact that the lawyers had experience and software tools that allowed them to perform their services more effectively should be considered in the comparability analysis when setting the service fee.
Key takeaway
Not every use of group IP in a service is a transfer of that IP. Where the recipient gets no right to use the IP itself, the service fee — calibrated for the team's enhanced effectiveness — is the full answer.
Related: Example 24 (where IP rights do transfer) · Chapter VII (intra-group services)