Use of intangibles in sales and services (main text)
Example 33 — Geological data and know-how used in exploration services
Chapter VI · main text · ¶6.106 · Exploration company · associated enterprise
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
An exploration company holds valuable geological data and analysis, as well as sophisticated exploratory software and know-how, which it has acquired or developed. It uses them to perform exploration services for an associated enterprise, which is assumed to acquire no rights in them. What part do these intangibles play when the services are priced?
The parties
Exploration company
Geological data and analysis · exploratory software · know-howexploration services
Associated enterprise
Receives the services · assumed to acquire no rights in the intangiblesWhat happens
- An exploration company holds valuable geological data and analysis and sophisticated exploratory software and know-how, which it has acquired or developed.
- It draws on those intangibles when performing exploration services for an associated enterprise.
- It is assumed that the associated enterprise obtains no rights in the exploration company's intangibles.
Analysis
In the controlled transaction, the exploration company performs exploration services for an associated enterprise with the help of its data, software and know-how. That enterprise is assumed to obtain no rights in those intangibles.
What part do the exploration company's intangibles play in the transfer pricing analysis of the services?
OECD analysis · Used in services, not transferred
This is a second illustration of intangibles being used in a controlled transaction without being transferred, this time in a provision of services. The geological data and analysis, the software and the know-how should be identified, and then taken into account when the comparability of the services is analysed, when the most appropriate method is selected and when the tested party is chosen. On the assumption that the associated enterprise acquires no rights in them, they are not transferred: they are used to perform the services and may affect the value of those services.
Key takeaway
Intangibles that a provider uses to perform services may affect the value of those services, and should be identified and taken into account when comparability is analysed and the method and tested party are chosen. That nothing is transferred rests on the assumption that the recipient acquires no rights in them.
Related: Section C.2 (use of intangibles in sales of goods or performance of services) · ¶6.105 (the same point for a sale of goods) · Sections D.1 and D.5 (supplemental guidance; ¶6.104 cites the latter as D.4, but in the 2022 edition it is Section D.5, ¶6.196–6.212)