Conduct overrides contract
Example 19 — Imputing a licence from substantial use
Annex I · Example 19 · ¶67–68
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company P built a successful retailing know-how and a unique marketing concept in Country A. Its new Country B subsidiary, Company S, uses the same know-how and concept and earns margins well above comparable Country B retailers. There is no licence on paper. Should there be?
The parties
Company P
Parent · developed know-how and marketing concept in Country Ause of know-how & concept (no written agreement)
Company S
Country B subsidiary · uses same know-how · above-market marginsWhat happens
- Company P develops special know-how and a unique marketing concept for its department-store business in Country A.
- The know-how and the marketing concept are assumed to be intangibles within the meaning of Chapter VI Section A.
- Company P establishes Company S in Country B; Company S operates new department stores using the same know-how and marketing concept.
- Company S earns profit margins substantially higher than comparable Country B retailers.
Analysis
Company S clearly uses Company P's know-how and marketing concept. Independent parties would have signed a licence to use them.
What should the tax administration do?
OECD analysis · Royalty imputed
The conduct of the parties reveals a transaction consisting of the transfer from Company P to Company S of the right to use the know-how and unique marketing concept. Independent parties in comparable circumstances would have entered into a licence agreement. One available remedy is to impute a royalty payment from Company S to Company P for the use of these intangibles.
Key takeaway
Use of group intangibles without a written licence is a transaction. Accurately delineated, it is whatever independent parties in comparable circumstances would have signed — typically a royalty-bearing licence.
Related: Example 18 (written licence too narrow) · Chapter I · Section D (accurate delineation)