Conduct overrides contract

Example 18 — Conduct widens the licence beyond its written terms

Annex I · Example 18 · ¶64–66

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Primarni licenses Company S to use Product X patents and know-how in Country B only. In practice, Company S sells Product X into associated distributors across Asia and Africa, and Primarni does not enforce its retained rights. Is this still a Country-B-only licence?
Primarni
Owner of Product X patents · retains rights in Asia & Africa
royalty (originally Country B only)
Company S
Licensee for Country B · in practice sells across Asia & Africa
  1. Primarni develops Product X patents and know-how, holding valid patents in all relevant countries.
  2. Written licence: Company S can use the patents/know-how to manufacture and sell Product X in Country B only.
  3. Primarni retains patent and know-how rights in Asia, Africa and Country A.
  4. Company S manufactures Product X in Country B and sells it both to independent and to associated distributors based across Asia and Africa.
  5. Primarni does not exercise its retained rights to prevent these sales.

In practice, Primarni lets Company S sell across Asia and Africa — not just Country B as the written licence says.

What is the real scope of the licence for transfer pricing?

OECD analysis · Licence extended by conduct
The conduct of the parties suggests that the actual transaction is a licence of the Product X patents and know-how for Country B plus Asia and Africa. Company S's licence should be treated as extending accordingly, and the royalty rate should be recalculated to take into account the total projected sales in all the relevant territories.
Key takeaway
Conduct can broaden — or narrow — a written licence. Where the principal tolerates exploitation outside the written scope, accurately delineated the licence covers what is actually used.

Related: Chapter I · Section D.1 · Example 19 (no licence on paper at all)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →