Marketing intangibles

Example 13 — From distributor to processor-licensee

Annex I · Example 13 · ¶42–45 · Primair group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same group, the Example 10 fact pattern. At the end of year 3, Primair stops manufacturing and outsources to a third party. Company S now imports unbranded watches, brands them, and operates under a new long-term royalty-bearing licence — with no compensation for the renegotiation. Is this arm's-length?
Third-party CM
Manufactures unbranded watches
unbranded watches
Primair
Brand owner · grants new processing/licence to Company S
new licence · royalty
Company S
Now processes, brands, distributes · pays gross-sales royalty
  1. Primair owns the R-brand watch trademark; Company S is its long-term exclusive distributor in Country Y.
  2. Years 1–3: Company S invests heavily in marketing under the distribution agreement, spending substantially more than comparable independents; margins fall well below comparables.
  3. End of year 3: Primair stops manufacturing and contracts a third-party CM. Company S will now import unbranded watches, brand and package them, and sell.
  4. Year 4: new 5-year (+5-year option) licence agreement signed; Company S pays a royalty on gross sales of all such watches.
  5. No compensation paid for the renegotiation; the new watch purchase price is assumed to be arm's-length with no R-name component embedded.

Years 1–3 look like Example 10 (over-investment). In years 4–5, Company S still over-spends on marketing vs. comparable long-term licensees and earns much less.

How can the tax administration fix the imbalance?

OECD analysis · Adjustment via royalty + renegotiation review
For years 1–3 the bases for adjustment are as in Example 10. For years 4–5 the bases are similar except the adjustment reduces the royalty payments rather than the purchase price. Depending on facts and circumstances, consideration could also be given to whether Company S should have received compensation for the year-3 renegotiation under Part II of Chapter IX.
Key takeaway
Restructures from distribution into licensing/processing don't reset history. The earlier period needs its own adjustment, the new period requires comparables for the new structure, and the renegotiation itself may warrant compensation under Chapter IX.

Related: Example 10 (years 1–3 logic) · Chapter IX · Part II (business restructurings)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →