Marketing intangibles
Example 12 — Royalty introduced mid-contract
Annex I · Example 12 · ¶39–41 · Primair group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same as Example 9. By end of year 3 the R brand is well established. Primair and Company S then sign a new long-term licence under which Company S pays a sales-based royalty — with no adjustment to the watch purchase price. Company S's margins fall well below comparables. Should the royalty be respected?
The parties
Primair
Brand owner · introduces new royalty without price reliefroyalty on gross sales → · no purchase-price adjustment
Company S
Long-term licensee · margins fall below comparablesWhat happens
- Primair owns the R-brand watch trademark; Company S is its long-term exclusive distributor in Country Y, having borne the marketing costs and risks itself.
- End of year 3: R brand well established in Country Y due to Company S's efforts.
- New long-term licence agreement signed (5 + 5 year option) under which Company S pays Primair a royalty based on gross sales of all R watches.
- No adjustment is made to the watch purchase price to reflect the new royalty.
- Years 4–5: Company S's marketing spend and activity remain at independent-distributor levels; profit margins fall substantially below comparables.
Analysis
Independent distributors in similar deals don't pay a royalty just for the right to distribute branded product. The new royalty pushes Company S's margins below those of comparables.
Should the new royalty be respected?
OECD analysis · Royalty disallowed
It would not generally be expected at arm's length that a royalty is paid where a marketing-and-distribution entity obtains no transfer-pricing rights in the trademark other than the right to use it in distributing branded product. The royalty causes margins to fall consistently below those of comparable distributors. Disallow the royalties.
Key takeaway
Mid-contract royalties can disguise erosion of distributor margin. If comparable independent distributors do not pay a royalty for the bare right to distribute, the controlled royalty should not survive.
Related: Example 9 (baseline) · Example 13 (manufacturing-licence variant)