Marketing intangibles

Example 11 — Short-term contract amplifies the imbalance

Annex I · Example 11 · ¶35–38 · Primair group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same as Example 9, except the marketing & distribution agreement is for three years only, with no renewal option and no renewal in fact. Company S nonetheless invests heavily in marketing. Does the short-term nature of the contract change anything?
Primair
Brand owner · benefits after contract ends
short-term marketing investment
Company S
3-year distributor · no renewal · invests in marketing
  1. Primair makes R-brand watches. Its affiliate Company S distributes them in Country Y, where the R name has no existing recognition.
  2. Year 1: 3-year marketing and distribution agreement signed; no renewal option.
  3. Company S incurs marketing and distribution expenses building the market.
  4. End of year 3: contract ends with no renewal.
  5. Independent comparables show short-term distributors only invest where reward is commensurate with within-contract returns.

Independent distributors wouldn't invest this much in marketing on a short contract without some protection. The R-brand goodwill Company S builds in Country Y will keep paying Primair after the contract ends.

Should Company S be compensated for the marketing value it built?

OECD analysis · Direct compensation or price reduction
Company S has assumed higher risks than in Example 9 and has not been compensated for them. The short-term contract makes it unreasonable to expect Company S to obtain appropriate benefits within the contract term. Compensation can take the form of a direct payment from Primair, or a reduction in the watch purchase price during years 1–3.
Key takeaway
Contract horizon matters. A short-term distributor that invests like a long-term partner cannot recoup the value within its window — the upside reverts to the principal and should be compensated.

Related: Example 9 (long-term variant) · Example 10 (excess spend variant)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →