Marketing intangibles

Example 10 — Distributor spends far above comparables

Annex I · Example 10 · ¶30–34 · Primair group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same long-term arrangement as Example 9, but Company S's marketing functions and spend in years 1–5 far exceed those of comparable independent distributors. Its margins end up significantly below comparables. Is the lower margin arm's-length?
Primair
Brand owner
watches · margin substantially below comparables
Company S
Long-term distributor · excess marketing spend and functions
  1. Primair makes R-brand watches; Company S is its long-term exclusive distributor in Country Y (R brand previously unknown there) and bears the marketing costs and risks itself, with the watch purchase price set lower to reflect that.
  2. Years 1–5: Company S incurs marketing spend substantially in excess of comparable independents.
  3. Excess spend reflects additional or more intensive functions expected to drive higher margins or volume.
  4. Company S's profit margins are significantly lower than comparables; brand develops successfully.

Company S has done more — and spent and risked more on marketing — than comparable independent distributors.

Is a transfer-pricing adjustment in Company S's favour warranted?

OECD analysis · Adjustment in Company S's favour
By performing functions and incurring marketing spend substantially in excess of comparable distributors, Company S has not been adequately compensated by the resale margins it earns. The Country Y tax administration could base an adjustment on (i) reducing the watch purchase price (RPM or TNMM), (ii) a residual profit split, or (iii) direct compensation for the excess marketing spend including an appropriate profit element.
Key takeaway
Excess marketing spend and functions, unmatched by margin, are evidence of an uncompensated contribution to marketing intangibles. Adjust by any of several routes — through price, residual split, or direct reimbursement-plus.

Related: Example 9 (matched comparables → no adjustment) · Example 11 (short-term contract variant)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →