Marketing intangibles
Example 9 — Distributor bears the marketing risk — long-term contract
Annex I · Example 9 · ¶26–29 · Primair group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same group as Example 8, but now Company S must develop the marketing plan, bear the marketing spend at its own risk, and look for its reward only in the distribution margin. The R brand becomes well established by end of year 2. Does Company S need extra compensation?
The parties
Primair
Brand owner · less control over executionwatches (lower purchase price reflects greater S risk)
Company S
Long-term exclusive distributor · bears marketing costs and risksWhat happens
- Primair owns the R-brand watch trademark. Its affiliate Company S is the long-term exclusive distributor in Country Y (5 years + 5-year option), where the R name has no existing recognition.
- Company S is obligated to develop and execute the marketing plan with best efforts; Primair does not approve detailed plan elements.
- Company S bears marketing costs and risks; no direct reimbursement, no separate marketing fee.
- Watch purchase price is set lower than in Example 8 to reflect S's greater functions and risks.
- Years 1–3: Company S incurs high marketing spend; brand becomes established by year 2.
Analysis
Independent distributors in similar long-term deals spend similar amounts on marketing — and Company S's profits track theirs.
Should Company S get extra compensation for its role in building the brand?
OECD analysis · No additional compensation
Where the marketer/distributor bears the costs and risks of its marketing activities, the issue is the extent to which it can share in the potential benefits. Here, Company S's profits are similar to those of independent marketers/distributors in comparable long-term arrangements for similarly unknown products. The comparables are the best measure of arm's-length return; no separate or additional compensation is required.
Key takeaway
A distributor that bears genuine marketing risk shares in the upside — but the comparables already capture that. Look for additional compensation only when functions and spend exceed what comparables show.
Related: Examples 8 (reimbursed counterpart) · Examples 10, 11 (where excess spend triggers adjustment)