Transfers & services with IP

Example 20 — Country-business migration — goodwill follows the value

Annex I · Example 20 · ¶69–72 · Ilcha group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company S1 ran the Product Q business in Countries B and C. The group then sets up Company S2 in Country C, transferring tangible assets and surrendering the relevant Rights so Ilcha can relicense them to S2. Has just legal title moved — or has business value moved with it?
Company S1 (Country B)
Surrenders Country C Rights · transfers tangible assets
surrender Rights · transfer assets
Ilcha
Parent · patent and trademark owner · relicenses
new long-term licence
Company S2 (Country C)
New operating company · receives Rights and assets
  1. Ilcha owns Product Q patents and the trademark; S1 had operated the Product Q business in Countries B and C for many years.
  2. Ilcha incorporates Company S2 in Country C.
  3. Company S1 transfers tangible manufacturing and marketing assets used in Country C to Company S2.
  4. Ilcha and Company S1 terminate the agreement granting S1 the Country C Rights (manufacture/distribute, use of patents/trademark, customer relationships, customer lists, goodwill).
  5. Ilcha grants Company S2 new long-term licences for the same Rights.

S1 built up real business value in Country C over the years. An independent buyer would pay for it — and accounting would call part of that price 'goodwill'.

What should the transfer prices in this restructuring reflect?

OECD analysis · Three transactions priced at full business value
There is value being transferred to Company S2 through the combination of the tangible-asset transfer and the surrender-and-relicensing of the Rights. There are three separate transactions: (i) S1 → S2 tangible assets, (ii) S1 → Ilcha surrender of Rights, (iii) Ilcha → S2 new licence. The prices paid should reflect the value of the business — including amounts that would be treated as goodwill for accounting purposes.
Key takeaway
Restructures don't destroy value. When a country business migrates, the prices on each leg must add up to the value an independent buyer would have paid for that business — including goodwill.

Related: Chapter IX (business restructurings) · Section D (transfers of intangibles)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →