DEMPE attribution
Example 15 — Autonomous R&D — legal owner sidelined
Annex I · Example 15 · ¶49–53 · Shuyona group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Same group, different R&D arrangement. Company S runs Product Line B globally — including the R&D — without reporting to Shuyona's R&D centre. Patents are still registered to Shuyona, with little or no payment to Company S. Does Shuyona keep the intangible returns?
The parties
Shuyona
Parent · legal owner/registrant · runs Product Line A onlyno payment / nominal payment to Company S ↑
Company S
Regional HQ · runs Product Line B globally · autonomous R&DWhat happens
- Shuyona runs all Product Line A R&D itself.
- Company S runs all Product Line B R&D and acts as global Product Line B HQ.
- Company S develops its own research programmes, budgets, staffing and project decisions.
- Patents from Company S's research are nonetheless registered by Shuyona, with no or only nominal payment to Company S.
- Joint meetings occur, but Company S does not report to Shuyona's R&D centre.
Analysis
Shuyona holds legal title to Product Line B patents — but Company S did all the research, with no real direction from Shuyona.
Who keeps the Product Line B intangible returns?
OECD analysis · Intangible returns to Company S
Because Shuyona neither performs nor controls the research, its legal ownership does not entitle it to retain or be attributed any income related to the Product Line B intangibles. The appropriate outcome can be achieved by ensuring Company S pays no royalty to Shuyona for using successfully developed Product Line B intangibles, so the future income flows to Company S. If Shuyona were to exploit those intangibles itself, it would need to compensate Company S — and Company S would be unlikely to be the tested party.
Key takeaway
Registering a patent in the parent's name does not transport the value there. Where the affiliate performs and controls DEMPE, the economic returns must follow — even if legal title sits elsewhere.
Related: Example 14 (mirror image) · Paragraph 6.56 (important functions)