DEMPE attribution

Example 15 — Autonomous R&D — legal owner sidelined

Annex I · Example 15 · ¶49–53 · Shuyona group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Same group, different R&D arrangement. Company S runs Product Line B globally — including the R&D — without reporting to Shuyona's R&D centre. Patents are still registered to Shuyona, with little or no payment to Company S. Does Shuyona keep the intangible returns?
Shuyona
Parent · legal owner/registrant · runs Product Line A only
no payment / nominal payment to Company S ↑
Company S
Regional HQ · runs Product Line B globally · autonomous R&D
  1. Shuyona runs all Product Line A R&D itself.
  2. Company S runs all Product Line B R&D and acts as global Product Line B HQ.
  3. Company S develops its own research programmes, budgets, staffing and project decisions.
  4. Patents from Company S's research are nonetheless registered by Shuyona, with no or only nominal payment to Company S.
  5. Joint meetings occur, but Company S does not report to Shuyona's R&D centre.

Shuyona holds legal title to Product Line B patents — but Company S did all the research, with no real direction from Shuyona.

Who keeps the Product Line B intangible returns?

OECD analysis · Intangible returns to Company S
Because Shuyona neither performs nor controls the research, its legal ownership does not entitle it to retain or be attributed any income related to the Product Line B intangibles. The appropriate outcome can be achieved by ensuring Company S pays no royalty to Shuyona for using successfully developed Product Line B intangibles, so the future income flows to Company S. If Shuyona were to exploit those intangibles itself, it would need to compensate Company S — and Company S would be unlikely to be the tested party.
Key takeaway
Registering a patent in the parent's name does not transport the value there. Where the affiliate performs and controls DEMPE, the economic returns must follow — even if legal title sits elsewhere.

Related: Example 14 (mirror image) · Paragraph 6.56 (important functions)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →