DEMPE attribution

Example 21 — Super-distributor that pays without performing

Annex I · Example 21 · ¶73–77 · Första group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Första shifts title to Product Y through Company S — a new super-distributor and invoicing centre. From year 2, Company S funds the distribution affiliates' advertising; from year 3, Första cuts the prices it charges Company S on the basis that Company S now 'owns' the marketing intangibles. Has it?
Första
Manufacturer · legal owner of Product Y trademark
products (title flips through S)
Company S
Super-distributor · invoicing centre · funds advertising
advertising reimbursement
Distribution affiliates
Receive products · run local advertising
  1. Pre-year 2: Första manufactures and ships Product Y direct to distribution affiliates; trademark premium accrues to Första.
  2. Year 2: Company S is set up as super-distributor/invoicing centre. Title to product passes through Company S but goods still ship direct.
  3. Year 2: Company S reimburses distribution affiliates for part of their advertising; affiliate prices adjusted up to keep affiliate margins constant.
  4. Year 3: Första reduces the prices it charges Company S, asserting Company S now 'owns' Product Y marketing intangibles.

Company S doesn't actually do any advertising work or control any marketing risk. And the advertising it 'funds' is recouped by raising the prices it charges affiliates.

Does Company S deserve marketing-intangible income?

OECD analysis · No DEMPE entitlement
In substance, Company S has no claim to income from exploiting Product Y intangibles. It performs no functions, assumes no risk and in substance bears no cost related to DEMPE — the affiliate price adjustments effectively recharge the advertising cost. Transfer pricing adjustments to increase Första's income from year 3 onwards are appropriate.
Key takeaway
Funding by itself — and even less, paper-funding that is recouped through pricing adjustments — does not generate intangible ownership. DEMPE substance is the gate.

Related: Examples 6, 16, 17 (funding-return cases) · Section B.2 (DEMPE framework)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →