DEMPE attribution

Example 14 — Contract R&D — parent controls

Annex I · Example 14 · ¶46–48 · Shuyona group

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Shuyona's R&D centre designs the group research programme, sets budgets, picks where R&D happens and monitors progress. Company S runs the work it is asked to run — and reports back monthly. Shuyona registers the resulting patents. Is Shuyona entitled to the intangible returns?
Shuyona
Parent R&D centre · designs programme · controls budgets and risk
directed R&D services · cost-plus fee
Company S
Project-by-project R&D under Shuyona's direction
  1. Shuyona's R&D centre designs the group's overall research programme.
  2. Company S R&D centre executes specific projects assigned by Shuyona; suggestions are formally approved by Shuyona.
  3. Company S reports at least monthly; budget over-runs require Shuyona R&D management approval.
  4. Contracts state Shuyona bears all R&D risks and costs; patents are registered by Shuyona.
  5. Shuyona pays Company S a service fee.

Shuyona is the legal owner and runs the show — budgets, programme design, funding, expenditure control — including Company S's research.

Who keeps the intangible returns, and what does Company S earn?

OECD analysis · Cost-plus / service fee
Shuyona is entitled to returns derived from exploiting the intangibles developed through the R&D of Company S. Company S is entitled to compensation for its functions performed, assets used, and risks assumed. Adjustments to reach a comparable R&D-service provider rate relate to the years services are provided and do not affect Shuyona's future intangible returns.
Key takeaway
Where the parent designs, funds, monitors and controls R&D, the affiliate is a service provider — not a co-owner of the IP. Returns from the intangible follow the party that performs and controls the important functions.

Related: Paragraph 6.56 (important functions) · Example 15 (autonomous variant)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →