Resale price method
Example 6 — Exclusive sales and technical applications
Chapter II · Resale price method · ¶2.44
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
In five jurisdictions a company sells a product through independent distributors that simply market it. In one other country, a market of strategic importance, its subsidiary must sell only the company's product and perform technical applications for customers. Can the independent distributors' margins be applied to the subsidiary?
The parties
The company
Supplier of the productproduct
Independent distributors
Five jurisdictions · simply market the productSubsidiary
One country · sells only the company's product · technical applicationsWhat happens
- In five jurisdictions where it has no subsidiaries, a company sells a product through independent distributors.
- All those distributors do is market the product; they perform no additional work.
- The company has created a subsidiary in one country.
- Given the strategic importance of that market, the subsidiary is required by the company to sell only the company's product and to carry out technical applications for customers.
Analysis
The margins on offer are derived from independent enterprises that have no exclusive sales arrangement and do not perform technical applications like those the subsidiary undertakes. In every other respect the facts and circumstances are taken to be similar.
Can those margins be applied to the subsidiary?
OECD analysis · Consider comparability adjustments
The subsidiary differs from the independent distributors in two ways: it sells only the company's product, and it performs technical applications for customers. Even where everything else about the facts and circumstances is similar, the Guidelines say, it has to be considered whether adjustments are needed to achieve comparability. They go no further than that. The paragraph does not say that an adjustment will always be needed, what it would be, or that the method fails.
Key takeaway
Margins earned by distributors that simply market a product cannot be applied unexamined to a distributor that sells exclusively and performs technical applications. Whether adjustments are needed to achieve comparability has to be considered first.
Related: Part II, Section C.2 (examples of the resale price method) · ¶2.112 (the same facts with the technical function performed by the comparables)