Resale price method
Example 5 — Who performs the warranty, and where the cost is booked
Chapter II · Resale price method · ¶2.43 · Distributor C · Distributor D
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
The downstream price is uniform, because a warranty comes with every product. Distributor C carries out the warranty function and is compensated for it through a lower price from the supplier; for Distributor D the supplier performs the function and charges a higher price. Does it matter how C accounts for the cost of the warranty work?
What happens
- The downstream price is uniform, because a warranty comes with every product.
- Distributor C carries out the warranty function itself; the supplier in fact compensates it for this by charging a lower price.
- The warranty function is not performed by Distributor D but by the supplier, with products going back to the factory.
- The price Distributor D pays its supplier is higher than the price charged to Distributor C.
The questions
A
Cost of goods sold is where Distributor C books the cost of performing the warranty function.
Is a separate adjustment needed before the gross profit margins of C and D are compared?
OECD analysis · Adjustment is automatic
Distributor C is compensated for the warranty function through a lower purchase price, and in this variation the cost of performing the function is recorded in cost of goods sold. On that footing, the Guidelines say, the gross profit margins adjust for the differences between C and D automatically. No further correction is called for.
B
Distributor C records its warranty expenses as operating expenses, not in cost of goods sold.
Can the gross profit margins of C and D be compared as reported?
OECD analysis · Distortion must be corrected
With the warranty expenses in operating expenses, the Guidelines find that the margins are distorted and that the distortion has to be corrected. Their reasoning runs through Distributor D: were D to perform the warranty function itself, its supplier would charge a lower transfer price, leaving D with a larger gross profit margin. The paragraph does not set out how the correction is to be made.
Key takeaway
Where a distributor is paid for a function through a lower purchase price, gross margins line up automatically only if the cost of that function is booked in cost of goods sold. If it is booked in operating expenses, the margins are distorted and must be corrected before they are compared.
Related: Part II, Section C.2 (examples of the resale price method) · ¶2.42 (a warranty offered by only one of two distributors)