Resale price method
Example 4 — A warranty from one distributor, none from the other
Chapter II · Resale price method · ¶2.42 · Distributor A · Distributor B
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Distributors A and B sell the same product, under the same brand name, in the same market. A offers a warranty and sells at a higher price, which gives it the higher gross profit margin so long as warranty servicing costs are left aside; B offers no warranty and sells for less. Can the two margins be compared as they stand?
What happens
- Two distributors, A and B, sell the same product under the same brand name in the same market.
- A warranty is offered by Distributor A but not by Distributor B.
- The warranty is not part of a pricing strategy on Distributor A's part, so A sells the product at a higher price than B.
- Before the costs of servicing the warranty are taken into account, Distributor A's gross profit margin is higher than Distributor B's.
Analysis
The warranty is the difference between the two distributors. Distributor A's higher price gives it a higher gross profit margin than Distributor B, so long as the costs of servicing the warranty are left out of account.
Are the gross profit margins of A and B comparable?
OECD analysis · Adjust before comparing
Product, market and brand are the same, but the warranty feeds into price and so into the gross margin. Distributor A's higher price produces a higher gross profit margin as long as the costs of servicing the warranty are left out. The Guidelines conclude that the margins cannot be compared until that difference has been adjusted for with reasonable accuracy. The implication is that the comparison can go ahead once such an adjustment has been made.
Key takeaway
The same product, market and brand do not guarantee comparable gross margins. A difference such as a warranty offered by only one distributor has to be adjusted for with reasonable accuracy before the margins are compared.
Related: Part II, Section C.2 (examples of the resale price method) · ¶2.43 (warranty function performed by the distributor or by the supplier) · ¶2.113 (the same facts where the warranty expenses cannot be ascertained)