CUP method

Example 3 — Same product, different volumes

Chapter II · CUP method · ¶2.26

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An associated enterprise in a taxpayer's MNE group pays the taxpayer USD 80 per ton for 1 000 tons of a product. An independent enterprise, buying 500 tons of the same product from the taxpayer at the same time, pays USD 100 per ton. What does the difference in volume mean for the transfer price?
Taxpayer
Seller of the product
same product, same time
Associated enterprise
1 000 tons · USD 80 per ton
Independent enterprise
500 tons · USD 100 per ton
  1. An associated enterprise in the taxpayer's MNE group buys 1 000 tons of a product from the taxpayer at USD 80 per ton.
  2. An independent enterprise buys 500 tons of the same product from the taxpayer at the same time, at USD 100 per ton.
  3. The product is the same in both sales; the volumes and the prices per ton differ.

The product and the timing are the same. The controlled sale is for the larger volume, 1 000 tons against 500 tons, and at the lower price, USD 80 against USD 100 per ton.

What does the difference in volume call for?

OECD analysis · Open: research volume discounts
The Guidelines do not say whether USD 80 per ton is an arm's-length price. What the case requires, they say, is an assessment of whether the difference in volume should lead to an adjustment of the transfer price. That means researching the relevant market: transactions in similar products are analysed to find out what volume discounts are typical. The outcome depends on what that research shows.
Key takeaway
A price charged to an independent enterprise for the same product cannot simply be carried over when the volumes differ. Whether the difference calls for an adjustment is a question for market research into typical volume discounts.

Related: Part II, Section B.2 (examples of the CUP method) · ¶2.25 (an adjustment for a difference in delivery terms)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →