CUP method
Example 2 — Delivered price against f.o.b. factory
Chapter II · CUP method · ¶2.25
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Controlled and uncontrolled sales are made in identical circumstances, with one exception: a delivered price applies to the controlled sales, whereas the uncontrolled ones are on f.o.b. factory terms. Does the difference in delivery terms stand in the way of the CUP method, or can it be dealt with?
What happens
- A delivered price is charged in the controlled sales.
- The uncontrolled sales are on f.o.b. factory terms.
- The two sets of sales therefore differ in their terms for transportation and insurance.
- In every other respect the circumstances surrounding the controlled and the uncontrolled sales are identical.
Analysis
The only difference between the controlled and the uncontrolled sales lies in the delivery terms: a delivered price on one side, f.o.b. factory on the other. It concerns transportation and insurance.
How should the uncontrolled sales price be used?
OECD analysis · Adjust for delivery terms
The Guidelines present this as a case where adjustments may be required. Transportation and insurance terms generally affect price in a way that is definite and can reasonably be ascertained. The difference in delivery terms should therefore be adjusted for when the uncontrolled sales price is determined. The difference is neither ignored nor treated as a reason to give up the comparison.
Key takeaway
A difference in delivery terms does not disqualify an uncontrolled price. Its effect on price can generally be ascertained, so the price is adjusted for it and the comparison goes ahead.
Related: Part II, Section B.2 (examples of the CUP method) · ¶2.24 (a difference in the product: coffee beans) · ¶2.26 (a difference in volume)