Cost plus method
Example 7 — Timing mechanisms: comparing gross mark-ups
Chapter II · Cost plus method · ¶2.59 · A · B · X, Y and Z
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A makes timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks and sells them to its foreign subsidiary B, earning a 5% gross profit mark-up. Independent manufacturers X, Y and Z make them for mass-market watches and earn 3% to 5%, but treat supervisory, general and administrative costs differently in their accounts. Can the mark-ups be compared as reported?
The parties
A
Domestic manufacturer · timing mechanisms for mass-market clockstiming mechanisms
B
Foreign subsidiary of AX, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country as A, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches and sell them to independent purchasers abroad.
What happens
- A manufactures timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks in its home country and sells them to B, its foreign subsidiary.
- On its manufacturing operation A earns a gross profit mark-up of 5%.
- X, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches, sell them to independent foreign purchasers and earn gross profit mark-ups of between 3% and 5% on their manufacturing operations.
- A books its supervisory, general and administrative costs as operating expenses, which keeps them out of cost of goods sold.
- For X, Y and Z, those costs are part of cost of goods sold and so are reflected in their gross profit mark-ups.
Analysis
A's 5% mark-up does not reflect supervisory, general and administrative costs, because A treats them as operating expenses. X, Y and Z carry those costs in cost of goods sold, so their mark-ups of 3% to 5% do reflect them.
Can A's mark-up be tested against those of X, Y and Z as reported?
OECD analysis · Adjust for accounting consistency
The reported figures are not measured on the same basis. A leaves supervisory, general and administrative costs out of cost of goods sold, whereas the mark-ups of X, Y and Z are struck after those costs. The Guidelines conclude that the mark-ups of X, Y and Z have to be adjusted so that the accounting is consistent. The example keeps X, Y and Z in the comparison even though their mechanisms are for watches; the one adjustment it calls for is an accounting one. It gives no adjusted figures and does not say whether A's mark-up proves to be at arm's length.
Key takeaway
A gross profit mark-up means little until you know which costs sit in cost of goods sold. Before mark-ups are compared under the cost plus method, the controlled and uncontrolled figures have to treat the same costs in the same way.
Related: Part II, Section D.2 (examples of the cost plus method) · ¶2.111 (net profit indicators where the costs to be adjusted cannot be identified)