Gross versus net profit indicators (Annex I)

Example 14 — Obsolescence risk: gross margin against net margin

Annex I to Ch.II · Illustration 2 · ¶3

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Two distributors each have sales of 1 000 of the same product. One has a buy-back clause under which the manufacturer purchases back all unsold inventory; the other assumes the obsolescence risk itself and pays a lower purchase price. If the difference in risk goes unidentified, which is further out: a gross margin test or a net margin test?
  1. Both distributors have sales of 1 000: volume, product, market and price are the same for both.
  2. Case 1, no obsolescence risk, because under a buy-back clause the manufacturer purchases back all unsold inventory: purchase price 700, gross margin 300 (30%), loss on obsolete inventory 0, other expenses (overheads) 250, net profit margin 50 (5%).
  3. Case 2, the distributor assumes the obsolescence risk and has no buy-back clause: purchase price 640, gross margin 360 (36%), loss on obsolete inventory 50, other expenses (overheads) 250, net profit margin 60 (6%).
  4. The purchase prices differ by 60, assumed to reflect who bears the obsolescence risk, manufacturer or distributor: an estimated additional loss of 50 plus remuneration for the distributor's risk. Put another way, 60 is what the buy-back clause costs.
  5. The controlled transaction follows case 1 and the third-party comparables follow case 2. The difference in the level of risk goes unidentified because the information on the comparables is not detailed enough.

The controlled transaction follows case 1 (gross margin 30%, net profit margin 5%) and the comparables follow case 2 (gross margin 36%, net profit margin 6%). The difference in the level of risk has not been identified.

Which margin is less sensitive to the unidentified difference in risk, and by how much?

OECD analysis · Net margin less sensitive here
Under a gross margin method the controlled distributor's 30% would be tested against the comparables' 36%, and the potential error could amount to 60 (6% × 1 000). Under a net margin method it is 10 (1% × 1 000), because the comparables that assume the risk also show a loss of 50 on obsolete inventory, which comes off after the gross margin. The Guidelines' lesson is that differences in the level of risk can affect net profit margins less than gross margins, depending on the circumstances and in particular on their effect on the cost structure and revenue of the comparables. That lesson assumes an arm's-length contractual allocation of risks. The figures are illustrative only and are not guidance on the choice of method or comparables.
Key takeaway
A difference in risk that is priced into the purchase price can distort a gross margin comparison more than a net margin comparison, because the party assuming the risk also carries the related loss below the gross margin. This depends on the circumstances and assumes an arm's-length contractual allocation of risk.

Related: Chapter II, Part III, Section B (transactional net margin method) · ¶2.76 (sensitivity of net profit indicators to differences in risk; refers to this annex) · Illustration 1 (difference in the marketing function)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →