Gross versus net profit indicators (Annex I)

Example 15 — Capacity utilisation: gross mark-up against net margin

Annex I to Ch.II · Illustration 3 · ¶4–5

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A product priced at 1 m.u. a unit is made and sold by two manufacturers of equal total capacity: one runs at full capacity, 1 000 units a year, the other at 80%, 800 units. Unit variable cost, fixed personnel costs and indirect costs are the same for both. If the difference in capacity utilisation goes unidentified, which indicator is further out?
  1. The two manufacturers have identical total capacity; each makes and sells the same product, on the same market, at 1 m.u. per unit; the arm's-length price is assumed not to be affected by capacity utilisation.
  2. Both have variable cost of goods sold of 0.75 m.u. per unit, fixed personnel costs of 50 within cost of goods sold, and indirect costs of 150.
  3. Case 1, full capacity of 1 000 units a year: sales 1 000, cost of goods sold 800 (variable 750, fixed 50), gross mark-up on cost of goods sold 200 (25%), net profit margin 50 (5%).
  4. Case 2, excess capacity, making 800 units a year or 80% of full capacity: sales 800, cost of goods sold 650 (variable 600, fixed 50), gross mark-up on cost of goods sold 150 (23%), net result break-even.
  5. The controlled transaction follows case 1 and the third-party comparables follow case 2. The difference in capacity utilisation goes unidentified because the information on the comparables is not detailed enough.

The controlled transaction follows case 1 (gross mark-up 25%, net profit margin 5%) and the comparables follow case 2 (gross mark-up 23%, break-even). The difference in capacity utilisation has not been identified.

Which indicator is more sensitive to the unidentified difference in capacity utilisation, and by how much?

OECD analysis · Net margin more sensitive here
Under a gross margin method the potential error could amount to 16 (2% × 800), the gross mark-up being 25% in case 1 and 23% in case 2. Under a net margin method it is 50 (5% × 1 000): indirect costs are 150 in both cases, so the manufacturer at full capacity earns 5% and the one with excess capacity only breaks even. The Guidelines explain that differences in the absorption of indirect fixed costs feed through to net profit, yet may leave the gross margin or gross mark-up unaffected if they are not reflected in price differences. Differences in capacity utilisation can therefore weigh more heavily on net profit indicators than on gross mark-ups or gross margins, depending on the facts, notably on how costs divide between fixed and variable and on which of the two, taxpayer or comparable, has the over-capacity. The figures are illustrative only and are not guidance on the choice of method or comparables.
Key takeaway
Net profit indicators are not always the more robust measure: where capacity utilisation differs, unabsorbed indirect fixed costs fall on net profit and may hardly show in the gross mark-up. How much this matters depends on how costs divide between fixed and variable, and on whether the excess capacity lies with the taxpayer or with the comparable.

Related: Chapter II, Part III, Section B (transactional net margin method) · ¶2.76 (capacity utilisation and net profit indicators; refers to this annex) · Illustrations 1 and 2 (where the net margin is the less sensitive measure)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →