Gross versus net profit indicators (Annex I)

Example 13 — Marketing function: gross margin against net margin

Annex I to Ch.II · Illustration 1 · ¶1–2

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Two distributors each have sales of 1 000, with the same product, market and price. One performs a limited marketing function, the other a more significant one, and the purchase price from the manufacturer takes account of that. If the difference goes unidentified, which is further out: a gross margin test or a net margin test?
  1. Both distributors have sales of 1 000: volume, product, market and price are the same for both.
  2. Case 1, a limited marketing function: purchase price from the manufacturer 600, gross margin 400 (40%), marketing expenses 50, other expenses (overheads) 300, net profit margin 50 (5%).
  3. Case 2, a more significant marketing function: purchase price 480, gross margin 520 (52%), marketing expenses 150, other expenses (overheads) 300, net profit margin 70 (7%).
  4. The purchase price differs by 120, which is assumed to reflect how much more extensive and complex the marketing function is in case 2: 100 of additional expense plus remuneration for the distributor's function.
  5. The taxpayer, which deals with an associated manufacturer, is in the position of case 2 and the third-party comparables are in that of case 1. The difference between their marketing functions goes unidentified, for instance because the information on the comparables is not detailed enough.

The taxpayer operates as in case 2 (gross margin 52%, net profit margin 7%) and the comparables as in case 1 (gross margin 40%, net profit margin 5%). The difference between the two marketing functions, in extent and complexity, has not been identified.

Which margin is less sensitive to the unidentified difference, and by how much?

OECD analysis · Net margin less sensitive here
Under a gross margin method the taxpayer's 52% would be tested against the comparables' 40%, and the potential error could amount to 120 (12% × 1 000). Under a net margin method, 7% against 5%, it would amount to 20 (2% × 1 000). Of the 120 difference in purchase price, 100 is additional marketing expense, which comes off after the gross margin. The Guidelines' lesson is that differences in the extent and complexity of functions can affect net profit margins less than gross margins, depending on the circumstances and in particular on their effect on the cost structure and revenue of the comparables. The figures are illustrative only and are not guidance on the choice of method or comparables.
Key takeaway
Functional differences that show up in operating expenses can move gross margins more than net margins. Whether they do depends on the circumstances, in particular on how the differences affect the cost structure and revenue of the comparables.

Related: Chapter II, Part III, Section B (transactional net margin method) · ¶2.76 (sensitivity of net profit indicators to functional differences; refers to this annex) · Illustrations 2 and 3 (differences in risk and in capacity utilisation)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →