Transactional net margin method
Example 12 — Warranty costs that cannot be ascertained
Chapter II · TNMM · ¶2.113 · Distributor A · Distributor B
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Distributors A and B sell the same product, under the same brand name, in the same market; A offers a warranty and sells at a higher price, B offers none. Here the amount of A's warranty expenses cannot be ascertained, so A's gross profit cannot be reliably adjusted. Is there another way to compare the two?
What happens
- Two distributors, A and B, sell the same product under the same brand name in the same market.
- Because its warranty is not offered as part of a pricing strategy, Distributor A charges a higher price for the product than Distributor B, which offers no warranty.
- Leaving the costs of servicing the warranty out of account, Distributor A's gross profit margin is higher than Distributor B's.
- It proves impossible to ascertain the amount of the warranty expenses that Distributor A incurs.
Analysis
Because A's warranty expenses cannot be ascertained, A's gross profit cannot be reliably adjusted to make its gross profit margin properly comparable with B's. Suppose A and B do not otherwise differ materially in their functions, and A's net profit relative to its sales is known.
What route do the Guidelines leave open?
OECD analysis · TNMM might be possible
A gross margin comparison is not available: without the amount of A's warranty expenses, A's gross profit cannot be reliably adjusted to make its margin properly comparable with B's. The Guidelines then look to net profit. Provided A and B do not otherwise differ materially in their functions and A's net profit relative to its sales is known, applying the transactional net margin method to B might be possible, by comparing A's ratio of net profit to sales with the ratio calculated on the same basis for B. The wording is tentative and conditional: the paragraph offers a possibility, not a guaranteed solution.
Key takeaway
When the cost behind a functional difference cannot be ascertained, a reliable gross margin adjustment is out of reach. A net margin comparison might still be possible, provided the functions do not otherwise differ materially and the ratio of net profit to sales is known.
Related: ¶2.42 (the base facts, under the resale price method) · ¶2.112 (net margins where the cost of a function cannot be identified) · Part III, Section B.4 (examples of the transactional net margin method)