Transactional net margin method

Example 11 — Comparables with an extra function, cost unknown

Chapter II · TNMM · ¶2.112

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A company uses independent distributors to sell a product in five jurisdictions; in one strategically important market it has a subsidiary. Here the independent distributors, not the subsidiary, perform technical support, and its cost, reported within cost of goods sold, cannot be separately identified. Which comparison can still be relied on?
The company
Supplier of the product
product
Independent distributors
Five jurisdictions · perform technical support
Subsidiary
One country · sells only the company's product · no technical support
  1. As in ¶2.44, a company uses independent distributors to sell a product in five jurisdictions where it has no subsidiaries, and has set up a subsidiary in one country.
  2. That one market is of strategic importance, and the subsidiary is required to sell only the company's product.
  3. Unlike in ¶2.44, the additional function of technical support is performed by the comparable independent enterprises and not by the subsidiary.
  4. What that function costs is reported within cost of goods sold and cannot be identified separately.

Technical support is an additional function performed by the comparable independent enterprises, not by the associated enterprise. Cost of goods sold is where its costs are reported, and they cannot be identified separately.

How do the Guidelines suggest the transfer price be assessed?

OECD analysis · Net margins, with caution
A CUP may be out of reach because of product and market differences. A resale price method would be unreliable, because the additional function, and the unknown additional costs that come with it, would call for a higher gross margin at the independent enterprises than at the subsidiary. In this situation, the Guidelines say, looking at net margins may be the more reliable way to gauge how far the transfer price should differ on account of the difference in function. They add a caution: comparability has to be taken into account, and net margins may not be reliable if the additional function or market differences would have a material effect on them.
Key takeaway
Where comparables perform an extra function whose cost cannot be separated out of cost of goods sold, a gross margin comparison becomes unreliable and net margins may be the more reliable measure. They are not immune: a material effect of the extra function, or of market differences, on net margin could undermine them too.

Related: ¶2.44 (the base facts, under the resale price method) · ¶2.111 (the similar approach where the costs needing adjustment cannot be identified) · Part III, Section B.4 (examples of the transactional net margin method)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →