Transactional net margin method

Example 10 — Timing mechanisms: costs that cannot be identified

Chapter II · TNMM · ¶2.111 · A · B · X, Y and Z

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
A makes timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks, sells them to its foreign subsidiary B and earns a 5% gross profit mark-up; the mark-ups of independent manufacturers X, Y and Z run from 3% to 5%. Those mark-ups, unlike A's, reflect supervisory, general and administrative costs, so an adjustment is needed. What if those costs cannot be identified?
A
Domestic manufacturer · timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks
timing mechanisms
B
Foreign subsidiary of A

X, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country as A, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches and sell them to independent purchasers abroad.

  1. A manufactures timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks in its home country, sells them to its foreign subsidiary B and earns a gross profit mark-up of 5% on its manufacturing operation.
  2. X, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches, sell them to independent foreign purchasers and earn gross profit mark-ups of between 3% and 5%.
  3. Supervisory, general and administrative costs are operating expenses in A's accounts but part of cost of goods sold in those of X, Y and Z, so the gross profit mark-ups of X, Y and Z reflect those costs and A's does not.
  4. It is known that the mark-ups of X, Y and Z need an adjustment for that difference.
  5. The supervisory, general and administrative costs within the cost of goods sold of X, Y and Z cannot be identified well enough to adjust the mark-ups for a reliable application of the cost plus method.

An adjustment to the mark-ups of X, Y and Z is known to be required, because they reflect supervisory, general and administrative costs and A's mark-up does not. The particular costs cannot be identified, so the mark-ups cannot be adjusted for a reliable application of cost plus.

What do the Guidelines suggest in that situation?

OECD analysis · May need net profit indicators
¶2.59 shows that gross mark-ups have to be adjusted before they can be compared consistently and reliably. If the costs concerned are easy to analyse, making that adjustment may present no difficulty. Here an adjustment is known to be required but the particular costs cannot be identified; the Guidelines say it may nevertheless be possible to identify the net profit on the transaction and in that way to use a consistent measure. For X, Y and Z that means net profit indicators may need to be examined, in the absence of more reliable comparisons. Both steps are hedged: the paragraph offers net profit as a route that may be open when a gross mark-up cannot be reliably adjusted, not as a certainty.
Key takeaway
Where gross mark-ups are known to need an adjustment but the costs behind it cannot be identified, it may still be possible to identify net profit and so compare on a consistent measure. Examining net profit indicators may then be necessary, in the absence of more reliable comparisons.

Related: ¶2.59 (the base facts, under the cost plus method) · ¶2.112 and ¶2.113 (net margins where the cost of a functional difference is unknown) · Part III, Section B.4 (examples of the transactional net margin method)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →