Example 10 — Timing mechanisms: costs that cannot be identified
Chapter II · TNMM · ¶2.111 · A · B · X, Y and Z
OECD Guidelines 2022The parties
X, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country as A, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches and sell them to independent purchasers abroad.
What happens
- A manufactures timing mechanisms for mass-market clocks in its home country, sells them to its foreign subsidiary B and earns a gross profit mark-up of 5% on its manufacturing operation.
- X, Y and Z, independent manufacturers in the same country, make timing mechanisms for mass-market watches, sell them to independent foreign purchasers and earn gross profit mark-ups of between 3% and 5%.
- Supervisory, general and administrative costs are operating expenses in A's accounts but part of cost of goods sold in those of X, Y and Z, so the gross profit mark-ups of X, Y and Z reflect those costs and A's does not.
- It is known that the mark-ups of X, Y and Z need an adjustment for that difference.
- The supervisory, general and administrative costs within the cost of goods sold of X, Y and Z cannot be identified well enough to adjust the mark-ups for a reliable application of the cost plus method.
Analysis
An adjustment to the mark-ups of X, Y and Z is known to be required, because they reflect supervisory, general and administrative costs and A's mark-up does not. The particular costs cannot be identified, so the mark-ups cannot be adjusted for a reliable application of cost plus.
What do the Guidelines suggest in that situation?
Related: ¶2.59 (the base facts, under the cost plus method) · ¶2.112 and ¶2.113 (net margins where the cost of a functional difference is unknown) · Part III, Section B.4 (examples of the transactional net margin method)