Captive insurance
Example 8 — Earthquake cover pooled through a captive
Chapter X · ¶10.223 · Manufacturing MNE group
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
An MNE group in manufacturing has 50 subsidiaries worldwide, each insuring against earthquake damage at a plant in a different location with a substantial earthquake risk. The group forms a captive insurance, which takes on the risk of every subsidiary and reinsures it with independent reinsurers. Who is entitled to the synergy benefit?
The parties
50 subsidiaries
Manufacturing plants · different locations · substantial earthquake riskearthquake risk insured
Captive insurance
Set up by the MNE group · accepts the risk from all subsidiariesrisk reinsured
Independent reinsurers
Reinsure the riskEvery plant is in a different location and is assessed on its own level of risk.
What happens
- An MNE group in manufacturing has 50 subsidiaries spread around the world, every one in a location with a substantial risk of earthquake.
- Each subsidiary insures its manufacturing plant against earthquake damage; every plant is in a different location and is assessed on its own level of risk.
- The MNE group forms a captive insurance, and all of the subsidiaries place their earthquake risk with it.
- The captive insurance in turn reinsures that risk with independent reinsurers.
Analysis
The captive insurance accepts the earthquake risk of all 50 subsidiaries, whose plants lie in different geographical zones, and reinsures it with independent reinsurers.
Who is entitled to the synergy benefit of the arrangement?
OECD analysis · Benefit to the insured
¶10.223. Because the pooled insurance risks span different geographical zones, the MNE group is already a diversified risk as far as the market is concerned. The synergy benefit is the product of the collective purchasing arrangement, not of value added by the captive insurance, and it should be divided among the insured by reference to the level of premium each contributed. Under ¶10.222, the captive insurance should be appropriately rewarded for the basic services it provides when it insures the risk and reinsures it in the open market; what is left of the synergy benefit should go to the insured participants through discounted premiums.
Key takeaway
A benefit that comes from buying insurance cover collectively is a group synergy, to be shared among the insured members by reference to the premiums they contributed. The reward due to the captive insurance is an appropriate one for the basic services it provides.
Related: Section E.3.3 (group synergy) · ¶10.222 (the captive's reward for basic services and discounted premiums)