Financial guarantees

Example 7 — Comparable guarantees priced at 1% to 1.5%

Chapter X · ¶10.187–10.188 · Example 2 · Company M · Company D

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Passive association lifts Company D's credit standing from a stand-alone BBB to A; an explicit guarantee from Company M, the group's AAA-rated parent, lifts it to AAA, where lenders charge 6%, not 8%. Comparable uncontrolled transactions put the arm's-length price of a comparable guarantee at 1% to 1.5%. Is a fee to be expected from Company D?
Company M
Parent entity of the MNE group · AAA rating
explicit guarantee
Company D
Group member · BBB stand-alone · A with passive association

The EUR 10 million that Company D needs is to be borrowed from an independent lender. At an A rating such lenders charge 8% interest, at AAA 6%. Comparable guarantees: arm's-length price of between 1% and 1.5%.

  1. Company M, an MNE group's parent entity, owes its AAA credit rating to the strength of the group's consolidated balance sheet.
  2. Company D belongs to the same group. Its stand-alone credit rating is only BBB, and it needs a loan of EUR 10 million from an independent lender.
  3. The effect of passive association is to lift Company D's credit standing from BBB to A; an explicit guarantee from Company M lifts it further, to AAA.
  4. The interest rate that independent lenders charge is 8% for an entity rated A and 6% for one rated AAA.
  5. Comparable uncontrolled transactions, found by applying the guidance in Section D.2, put the arm's-length price of a comparable guarantee between 1% and 1.5%.

The facts are those of Example 1 in the same section of the Guidelines (¶10.184–10.186), in which Company M charged a fee of 3%. What is new is the comparables: they price a comparable guarantee, at arm's length, at between 1% and 1.5%.

For the explicit guarantee, would Company D be expected to pay Company M a fee?

OECD analysis · Arm's-length fee expected
¶10.188. The accurate delineation traces the step from A to AAA in Company D's credit standing to a deliberate concerted group action: Company M's guarantee. The earlier step, from BBB to A, was the effect of passive association. Because Company D is better off than it would be without the guarantee, it would be expected to be willing to pay Company M an arm's-length guarantee fee. The assumed comparables price a comparable guarantee at between 1% and 1.5%; the example does not return to the 3% fee charged in Example 1 of Section D.3 (¶10.184–10.186).
Key takeaway
An explicit guarantee is a deliberate concerted group action, and the credit enhancement it adds on top of passive association can carry a fee. A borrower that is better off with the guarantee than without it would be expected to be willing to pay an arm's-length fee for it.

Related: Example 6 on this page (Example 1 of Section D.3, ¶10.184–10.186: the same facts with a 3% fee) · Section D.2 (determining the arm's-length price of guarantees) · Section D.8 of Chapter I, in particular ¶1.187 (MNE group synergies)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →