Financial guarantees

Example 6 — A 3% fee for a parent's explicit guarantee

Chapter X · ¶10.184–10.186 · Example 1 · Company M · Company D

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company D needs EUR 10 million from an independent lender, and its stand-alone credit rating is only BBB. Passive association lifts its credit standing to A, and an explicit guarantee from Company M, the group's AAA-rated parent, lifts it to AAA, where lenders charge 6%, not 8%; Company M's fee is 3%. Would an independent borrower pay that fee?
Company M
Parent entity of the MNE group · AAA rating
explicit guarantee (for a 3% fee)
Company D
Group member · BBB stand-alone · A with passive association

The EUR 10 million that Company D needs is to be borrowed from an independent lender. At an A rating such lenders charge 8% interest, at AAA 6%.

  1. Company M, an MNE group's parent entity, owes its AAA credit rating to the strength of the group's consolidated balance sheet.
  2. Company D belongs to the same group. Its stand-alone credit rating is only BBB, and it needs a loan of EUR 10 million from an independent lender.
  3. The effect of passive association is to lift Company D's credit standing from BBB to A; an explicit guarantee from Company M lifts it further, to AAA.
  4. The interest rate that independent lenders charge is 8% for an entity rated A and 6% for one rated AAA.
  5. Company D is charged a fee of 3% by Company M for the guarantee.

The explicit guarantee takes Company D's credit standing from A to AAA. Independent lenders charge 8% at A and 6% at AAA, and Company M's fee for the guarantee is 3%.

If an independent enterprise borrowed on Company D's conditions, would it be expected to pay Company M the 3% fee?

OECD analysis · Better off without the guarantee
¶10.185–10.186. The benefit that comes from the guarantee is the move from A to AAA, which is the difference between borrowing at 8% and at 6%; the move from BBB to A is the effect of passive association. A fee of 3% more than offsets that benefit, so Company D is better off without the guarantee. On a Chapter I analysis, this may indicate that an independent enterprise in Company D's position as borrower would not be expected to pay Company M 3% for the explicit guarantee. The text goes no further than "may indicate", and its conclusion concerns a fee of 3%, not every possible fee.
Key takeaway
Test a guarantee fee from the borrower's side: compare it with the benefit that the explicit guarantee itself adds, beyond the effect of passive association. Where the fee more than offsets that benefit, an independent borrower may not be expected to pay it.

Related: Section D.3 (examples on financial guarantees) · Section D.8 of Chapter I, in particular ¶1.187 (MNE group synergies) · Example 7 on this page (Example 2 of Section D.3, ¶10.187–10.188: the same facts with comparables for the fee)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →