Captive insurance
Example 9 — Insurance sold at the retailer's point of sale
Chapter X · ¶10.225–10.226 · Company A · Company B
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A, a high street retailer that sells high-value new technology consumer goods, offers customers 3-year accidental damage and theft cover at the point of sale. The policies are very profitable: Company B, a group insurer, insures them and takes substantially all of the profit, while A receives a commission. Is that split arm's length?
The parties
Company B
Insurer in the same MNE group · takes substantially all of the profitinsures the policies
Company A
High street retailer · sales agent · receives a commissionoffered at the point of sale
Third-party customers
Buy the goods · 3-year accidental damage and theft coverWhat happens
- Company A sells high-value new technology consumer goods as a high street retailer.
- Third-party customers are offered a policy by A at the point of sale, covering accidental damage and theft for a 3-year period.
- Company B, an insurer in the same MNE group as A, insures the policies; A is paid a commission, and B receives substantially all of the profit made on the insurance contracts.
- Two findings come out of a full factual and functional analysis: the insurance contracts are very profitable, and the type of risk they cover has an active insurance and reinsurance market.
- Benchmarking puts A's commission in line with independent agents that sell similar cover as a standalone product; B earns more profit than insurers that provide similar cover.
Analysis
A's commission is in line with what independent agents receive for selling similar cover as a standalone product, while B earns more profit than insurers that provide similar cover. The policy is substantially the same as what any insurer in the general market could offer, and A offers it when it sells the goods to be insured.
How should the profit on the policies be divided between A and B?
OECD analysis · Balance of profit to A
¶10.226. What matters is how the high profitability arises and what each party contributes to it. Substantially the same policy is available from any other insurer in the general market; the chance of a high profit comes from A's advantage of contact with the customer at the point of sale. A has an alternative, since it could have another insurer underwrite the policies and still keep most of the profit, whereas no other agent that B could find has that advantage. B's arm's-length remuneration would therefore be in line with the benchmarked return of insurers that insure similar risks, and the rest of the profit should be allocated to A.
Key takeaway
Where a sale earns an unusually high profit, find out what creates that profit before dividing it. Here it is the agent's contact with the customer at the point of sale, so the insurer earns a benchmarked insurer's return and the rest goes to the agent.
Related: Section E.3.4 (agency sales) · ¶10.224 (circumstances behind a high profit on insurance sold through an agent)