Delineating intra-group loans

Example 3 — A 10-year loan the borrower could not service

Chapter X · ¶10.13 · Company B · Company C

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company B, which belongs to an MNE group, needs more funding for its business and receives an advance from related Company C, labelled a 10-year loan. Company B's good-faith financial projections for those 10 years make clear that it could not service a loan of that amount. How much of the advance is a loan for transfer pricing purposes?
Company C
Related company · advances the funds
advance labelled a 10-year loan
Company B
MNE group member · needs additional funding
  1. Company B belongs to an MNE group and needs more funding for its business activities.
  2. A related company, Company C, advances the funds; the advance is labelled a 10-year loan.
  3. Every good-faith financial projection for Company B over the next 10 years shows clearly that it could not service a loan of that amount.

The advance is labelled a 10-year loan. Company B's good-faith financial projections for that period make clear that it could not service a loan of that amount.

How much of Company C's advance is delineated as a loan for transfer pricing purposes?

OECD analysis · Remainder is not a loan
¶10.13. The facts and circumstances support the conclusion that an unrelated party would not have made such a loan to Company B, because Company B could not repay it. The amount accurately delineated as a loan is therefore a function of two maximums: what an unrelated lender would have been prepared to advance to Company B, and what a comparably placed unrelated borrower would have been prepared to borrow from Company C. Either may be nil. The remainder of the advance is not delineated as a loan when determining the arm's-length interest payable by Company B. The example does not say what the remainder is instead, although ¶10.10 names a contribution to equity capital in particular as the other kind of payment a purported loan may turn out to be.
Key takeaway
Calling an advance a loan does not make all of it a loan: under accurate delineation, the amount delineated as a loan depends on what an unrelated lender would have lent and an unrelated borrower would have borrowed. The Guidelines give this guidance for jurisdictions that use accurate delineation to decide whether a purported loan is a loan (¶10.10).

Related: Section B.1 (whether a purported loan should be regarded as a loan) · Section C.1.1.1 (the lender's and borrower's perspectives) · ¶10.12 (indicators for delineating an advance of funds)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →