Delineating intra-group loans
Example 4 — A lender that does not control the risks
Chapter X · ¶10.25 · Company A · Company B · Company P
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A advances funds to Company B but, as accurate delineation shows, performs no control functions in relation to the advance. Company P, the MNE group's parent company, exercises control over the risks of the advance and has the financial capacity to assume them. What return is Company A entitled to?
The parties
Company A
Advances the funds · no control functionsadvance of funds
Company B
Receives the fundsCompany P, the MNE group's parent company, exercises control over the risks of the advance and has the financial capacity to assume them.
What happens
- The advance of funds is made by Company A to Company B.
- Company A exercises no control functions in connection with the advance.
- The MNE group's parent company, Company P, exercises control over the risks associated with the advance and has the financial capacity to assume them.
Analysis
Company A provides the funds but, on an accurate delineation of the actual transaction, performs no control functions in relation to the advance. Company P exercises control over the risks of the advance and has the financial capacity to assume them.
What return is Company A entitled to on the advance?
OECD analysis · Risk-free return at most
¶10.25. Where accurate delineation shows that the lender does not control the risks attached to its advance, or lacks the financial capacity to assume them, those risks should be allocated to the enterprise that exercises control and has the financial capacity (the paragraph refers to ¶1.98 of Chapter I). Here that enterprise is Company P. Under the Chapter I analysis, Company P therefore bears the consequences of the risks playing out, and Company A is entitled to no more than a risk-free return (the paragraph refers to Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I).
Key takeaway
A company that advances funds without controlling the risks of the advance does not end up with those risks. They should be allocated to the enterprise that controls them and has the financial capacity to assume them, and the funder is entitled to no more than a risk-free return.
Related: Section B.3.2 (functional analysis) · ¶1.98 of Chapter I (allocating risk to the enterprise with control and financial capacity) · Section D.1.2.1 of Chapter I (analysis of risks in commercial or financial relations)