Risk analysis in six steps

Example 8 — Outsourced research and the development risk

Chapter I · Example 1 (risk) · ¶1.83, 1.87, 1.90, 1.101 · Company A · Company B

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A has a development opportunity it wants to pursue, and for part of the research it engages a specialist, Company B. The contract places the development risk with Company A, which decides on the research and its budget and assesses progress at milestones. Who bears the outcome, and what if the contract put the risk on Company B instead?
Company A
Decides type of research, objectives and budget · assesses progress
research objectives and budget → · milestone reports ←
Company B
Specialist company · carries out part of the research day to day
  1. Company A wants to pursue a development opportunity. It decides to do part of the development work itself and to seek specialist input.
  2. Company A engages Company B, a specialist company, to carry out part of the research for it. Under the contract the development risk is assumed by Company A.
  3. Company A decides what type of research is to be carried out, which objectives are assigned to it and what budget is allocated to Company B.
  4. Company B takes on the day-to-day responsibility for the research and reports to Company A at milestones fixed in advance.
  5. Company A assesses how the development is progressing and whether it still meets Company A's ongoing objectives, and decides in that light whether continued investment in the project is warranted.
A

Development risk is the economically significant risk. Company A assumes it under the contract, takes the decisions on it and has the financial capacity to assume it. Company B cannot evaluate that risk; its own decisions concern the processes, expertise and assets it needs to do its research competently.

Who bears the consequences of the development risk, and what is Company B rewarded for?

OECD analysis · Development risk with Company A
Company A assumes the development risk under the contract, both companies do what the contract requires, and Company A controls the risk through its own decisions and has the financial capacity to assume it, so step 5 is not needed (¶1.87). Outsourcing the research to Company B is how Company A has mitigated its risk. Company B's own risk is mainly that of performing the research competently, which it controls and which is distinct from the development risk. Company A should therefore carry the financial consequences of failure and enjoy those of success, and Company B should receive an appropriate reward for its development services, allowing for the risk that it fails to perform them competently (¶1.101).
B

One fact changes: the contract now allocates the development risk to Company B, not to Company A. Nothing in the parties' conduct suggests that this allocation is not being followed. Everything else is as before: Company B still cannot evaluate the development risk and takes no decisions about Company A's activities.

How does the risk analysis deal with the development risk now?

OECD analysis · On to step 5
Step 4(i) raises no difficulty: the parties' conduct gives no sign that the contract is not being followed, so Company B contractually assumes the development risk. Step 4(ii) is not met, because Company B still cannot evaluate the risk, takes no decisions about Company A's activities and has no decision-making function that would let it control the risk. On the facts of the example it is Company A that controls the development risk. The party assuming the risk is thus not the party controlling it, and the analysis has to go on to step 5. ¶1.90 stops at that point; under step 5 the risk should go to the enterprise that exercises control and has the financial capacity to assume it (¶1.98).
Key takeaway
A contractual assumption of risk stands where the party acts on it in practice, controls the risk and can bear it financially; where the party assuming a risk does not control it, the analysis moves on to step 5. A service provider that controls only the risk of doing its own work competently is rewarded for the service, with that risk reflected in its reward.

Related: Section D.1.2.1.3 (step 3: functional analysis in relation to risk) · ¶1.62 (contract R&D: the reward for risk mitigation done through the development work is part of the service payment) · ¶1.98 (step 5: allocation of risk)

Test yourself on this example, question by question.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →