Economic significance of risk
Example 7 — Toy retailing: which risk matters?
Chapter I · ¶1.75 · Multinational toy retailer
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
A multinational toy retailer buys its wide product range from a number of third-party manufacturers and makes most of its sales in the last two months of the calendar year. Trends and demand can differ from one market to another. Which risk is economically significant in a business like this?
The parties
Third-party manufacturers
A number of manufacturers supplying the retailera wide range of products
Multinational toy retailer
Most sales in the last two months of the calendar yearThe Guidelines describe the retailer's business as a whole. No controlled transaction is specified.
What happens
- A number of third-party manufacturers supply the wide range of products that a multinational toy retailer buys.
- Trends and product demand can differ from one market to another.
- Most of the retailer's sales fall in the last two months of the calendar year.
Analysis
The retailer's products come from a number of third-party manufacturers, and most of its sales fall in the last two months of the calendar year. Trends and demand can differ from market to market.
Where do the Guidelines locate a significant risk for this retailer?
OECD analysis · Buying risk
For this retailer a significant risk sits in the buying function: the strategic direction it takes, and whether it bets correctly on trends and picks the products that will sell, in the right volumes. Trends and demand can differ from market to market, so judging the right bets takes expertise in the local market. A period of exclusivity negotiated with a manufacturer for a particular product can magnify the effect of the buying risk. The paragraph identifies the risk and goes no further: it does not say which entity in the group assumes or controls it.
Key takeaway
Significant risks should be identified with specificity: here the Guidelines point to one in the buying function, in its strategic direction and its bets on trends, products and volumes. Where trends and demand differ by market, expertise in the local market is needed to judge those bets.
Related: Section D.1.2.1.1 (step 1: identify economically significant risks with specificity) · ¶1.73 (economic significance as part of the broader functional analysis) · ¶1.74 (the first situation: a heating oil distributor)