Economic significance of risk

Example 6 — Heating oil distribution: how does risk matter?

Chapter I · ¶1.74 · Heating oil distributor

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An MNE group distributes heating oil to consumers: an undifferentiated product in a competitive market of predictable size, in which the players are price-takers. The credit terms the distributor achieves by managing its relationship with the oil suppliers fund its working capital. What is economically significant about risk in such a business?
Oil suppliers
Their credit terms fund the distributor's working capital
credit terms
MNE group
Distributes heating oil · a price-taker in a competitive market
heating oil
Consumers
Buy an undifferentiated product

The Guidelines describe the business of the group as a whole. No controlled transaction is specified.

  1. The business of an MNE group is the distribution of heating oil to consumers.
  2. Heating oil is an undifferentiated product, and the market for it is competitive.
  3. The size of the market is predictable, and those active in it are price-takers.
  4. The distributor manages its relationship with the oil suppliers and achieves credit terms from them, which fund its working capital.

With an undifferentiated product and price-taking players in a market of predictable size, there may be little scope to influence margins. Working capital is funded by the credit terms obtained from the oil suppliers, and those terms are crucial to the distributor's margin.

What do the Guidelines single out as significant about risk in this business?

OECD analysis · Cost-of-capital impact is significant
With an undifferentiated product, a competitive market of predictable size and price-taking players, the distributor's ability to influence its margins may be limited. Its working capital is funded by the credit terms it achieves through managing its relationship with the oil suppliers, and those terms are crucial to its margin. That is why the impact of the risk on the cost of capital is significant here, given how the distribution function creates value. The paragraph does not name that risk or say which entity assumes it: significance is judged against how the business creates value (¶1.73).
Key takeaway
The economic significance of a risk is judged in the context of how the business creates value. Where the product, the market and prices leave little room to influence margins, the effect of risk on the cost of capital can be what matters.

Related: Section D.1.2.1.1 (step 1: identify economically significant risks with specificity) · ¶1.73 (economic significance as part of the broader functional analysis) · ¶1.75 (the second situation: a multinational toy retailer)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →