Control over risk

Example 5 — Investor and fund manager: who controls the risk?

Chapter I · ¶1.70 · Investor · fund manager

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
An investor engages a fund manager, who is to invest money on the investor's account. Depending on their agreement, the manager may be authorised to make the day-to-day portfolio investments in line with the investor's risk preferences, while any loss in value would fall on the investor. Is it now the manager who controls the investment risk?
Investor
Engages the fund manager · would bear a loss in value of the investment
funds to invest on the investor's account
Fund manager
Invests on the investor's account · would generally report back regularly

The Guidelines use an investor and a fund manager to illustrate the concept of control. They are not described as associated enterprises.

  1. An investor engages a fund manager to invest money on the investor's account.
  2. Their agreement may give the fund manager authority over the day-to-day portfolio investments, to be made on the investor's behalf and in line with the investor's risk preferences.
  3. The risk that the investment loses value would be borne by the investor.
  4. The fund manager would generally have to give the investor regular reports, because the investor would want to judge how the manager's activities have turned out.

The investor decides on its risk preference (and so the diversification it requires), on hiring this fund manager or ending its contract, on the manager's authority and objectives, and on the amount to be managed. The day-to-day investment decisions are left to the fund manager.

Who controls the investment risk?

OECD analysis · Investor keeps control
The investor controls its risk through the four decisions it takes itself: on risk preference and diversification, on the choice of fund manager, on the manager's authority and objectives, and on the amount to be managed. The fund manager provides a service and manages its own business risk, for example to protect its credibility. That operational risk, which includes the chance of losing a client, is a different risk from the client's investment risk. So an investor who authorises another person to carry out risk mitigation of this kind has not necessarily handed control of the investment risk to the person taking the day-to-day decisions.
Key takeaway
Authorising another party to take the day-to-day decisions that mitigate a risk does not necessarily transfer control of that risk. The provider's own business risk is a different risk from the one it manages for its client.

Related: Section D.1.2.1 (analysis of risks in commercial or financial relations) · ¶1.65 (what control over risk requires, including where mitigation is outsourced) · ¶1.69 (the companion example: outsourced manufacturing and quality control)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →