Control over risk

Example 4 — Control over risk when the work is outsourced

Chapter I · ¶1.69 · Company A · Company B · Company C

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A has its products made by a specialist manufacturer, Company B, and engages Company C to carry out regular quality controls of the production process. The contractual relations imply that the inventory risk and the product recall risk lie with Company A. With others doing the day-to-day work, does Company A control those risks?
Company A
Provides product specifications and designs · determines production scheduling
specifications, designs and production scheduling
Company B
Specialist manufacturer · performs manufacturing services

Company A also engages Company C to carry out regular quality controls of the production process. Company C reports directly to Company A.

  1. Company B, a specialist manufacturer, is appointed by Company A to make products on Company A's behalf.
  2. Under the contractual arrangements Company B performs manufacturing services. Company A supplies the product specifications and designs and sets the production schedule, including volumes and the timing of product delivery.
  3. By implication from the contractual relations, the inventory risk and the product recall risk lie with Company A.
  4. Company A engages Company C to carry out regular quality controls of the production process, and tells it what the audits are to achieve and what information to gather on Company A's behalf.
  5. Company C's reports go directly to Company A.

Companies B and C do the manufacturing and the quality checks. Company A set the objectives of that outsourced work and chose both providers; it assesses whether those objectives are being adequately met and, if need be, decides to adapt or terminate the contracts.

Who controls the product recall and inventory risks?

OECD analysis · Company A controls
Control over risk means the capability to decide whether to take on a risk and whether and how to respond to it, together with actually taking those decisions; performing the day-to-day mitigation is not required (¶1.65). Company A takes the relevant decisions on its product recall and inventory risks. It also has the capability to assess and decide on the outsourced mitigation, and does so: it set the objectives, chose the providers, assesses whether they are adequately met and, where necessary, decides to adapt or terminate the contracts. Company A therefore controls both risks.
Key takeaway
Day-to-day mitigation of a risk can be outsourced without giving up control of that risk. Control stays with the party that has the capability to set the objectives, choose the provider, assess the results and adapt or end the arrangement, and that actually does so.

Related: Section D.1.2.1 (analysis of risks in commercial or financial relations) · ¶1.65 (what control over risk requires, including where mitigation is outsourced) · ¶1.70 (the companion example: investor and fund manager)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →