Contract versus conduct
Example 3 — Services paid for by the parent, with no recharge
Chapter I · ¶1.50 · Company P · its subsidiaries
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company P engages an independent party whose services are received by Company P's subsidiaries, and Company P pays for them. The subsidiaries do not reimburse it, either directly or through the price of another transaction, and no service agreement exists between them and Company P. Is there a controlled transaction to analyse at all?
The parties
Company P
Engages the independent party · pays for the servicesengagement and payment
Independent party
Provides the servicesservices
Subsidiaries of Company P
Receive the services · do not reimburse Company PCompany P and its subsidiaries have not put a service agreement in place between them.
What happens
- Company P engages an independent party to provide services.
- The services are received by Company P's subsidiaries.
- The bill for the services is paid by Company P.
- The subsidiaries do not pay Company P back: not directly, and not indirectly by way of the price of some other transaction.
- Company P and the subsidiaries have no service agreement between them.
Analysis
The MNE has not identified any transaction between Company P and its subsidiaries: there is no service agreement and nothing is reimbursed. Yet the subsidiaries receive services from a provider that Company P engaged and paid.
Is there anything between Company P and its subsidiaries for the transfer pricing analysis to delineate?
OECD analysis · A transaction to delineate
The absence of a contract or a charge does not mean that there is no transaction. The independent party's provision of services to the subsidiaries is not the whole picture: Company P and the subsidiaries also have commercial or financial relations of their own, through which potential value passes from Company P to the subsidiaries. The Guidelines do not say what those relations amount to. Their nature has to be established from the economically relevant characteristics, and only then can the terms and conditions of the transaction so identified be determined.
Key takeaway
A transfer of value can exist even where the group has not identified, documented or charged for it. Where nothing has been formalised, every aspect of the transaction has to be inferred from what the parties actually do.
Related: Section D.1.1 (the contractual terms of the transaction) · ¶1.49 (relations the MNE has not identified as a transaction, deduced from conduct)