Contract versus conduct
Example 2 — A written licence and what the licensor actually does
Chapter I · ¶1.48 · Company P · Company S
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
By written contract, Company P licenses intellectual property to its wholly-owned subsidiary, Company S, in return for a royalty. In practice Company P negotiates Company S's sales and supplies technical support and staff, and most customers insist on having it as joint contracting party. Is the transaction between the two really a licence?
The parties
Company P
Parent · licensor on paper · negotiates sales, provides support and staffwritten licence of intellectual property → · royalty ←
Company S
Wholly-owned subsidiary · licensee on paper · fee income payable to itMost customers insist that Company P be made a joint contracting party alongside Company S.
What happens
- Company P wholly owns its subsidiary, Company S.
- The two enter into a written contract: Company P grants Company S a licence of intellectual property for use in Company S's business, and Company S agrees to pay a royalty in return.
- To achieve sales for Company S, it is Company P that negotiates with the third-party customers.
- Company P gives Company S regular technical services support and regularly provides staff, so that Company S can deliver on and fulfil its customer contracts.
- The fee income under the customer contracts is payable to Company S, although most customers insist that Company P be made a joint contracting party alongside it.
Analysis
Without significant support from Company P, Company S could not deliver the services it has contracted to provide to customers, and it is not building up a capability of its own. On paper, Company P is only its licensor.
Is the transaction between Company P and Company S the licence that the written contract describes?
OECD analysis · Principal, not licensor
Company P negotiates the sales, supplies technical support and staff, and is the joint contracting party most customers insist on; Company S cannot perform without that support and is not building its own capability. Company P thus controls Company S's business risk and output: it has not passed on risk and function as a licensing arrangement would, and it acts as principal rather than licensor. The actual transaction is therefore determined from conduct, not solely from the written contract. The example stops at the finding that functions, assets and risks are inconsistent with the licence agreement; it does not price the arrangement.
Key takeaway
Where conduct departs materially from the written contract, it is the functions the parties in fact perform, the assets they use and the risks they assume, seen in the context of the contract, that delineate the transaction. A label such as 'licence' does not decide the matter.
Related: Section D.1.1 (the contractual terms of the transaction) · ¶1.45–1.46 (conduct that is inconsistent with the written contract) · ¶1.44 (the previous example: a contract that is silent, not contradicted)