Contract versus conduct

Example 1 — An agency contract that is silent on marketing

Chapter I · ¶1.44 · Company P · Company S

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company S acts as agent for the branded products of its parent, Company P, in the Country S market. Their agency contract says nothing about marketing or advertising, yet Company S has launched an intensive media campaign there to build brand awareness, a significant investment for it. Can the analysis stop at the written contract?
Company P
Parent of the MNE group · Country P
agency contract (silent on marketing and advertising)
Company S
Wholly-owned subsidiary · Country S · agent for Company P's branded products
  1. Company P, situated in Country P, heads an MNE group as its parent company. It wholly owns Company S, situated in Country S.
  2. Under an agency contract between the two, Company S is the agent in the Country S market for Company P's branded products.
  3. The contract does not say what marketing or advertising either party is to carry out in Country S.
  4. To develop brand awareness, Company S launches a media campaign in Country S. For Company S, this intensive campaign is a significant investment.

Nothing in the agency contract deals with marketing or advertising in Country S. The functional analysis nevertheless finds that Company S launched an intensive media campaign there, a significant investment for it.

How should the analysis treat a campaign that the written contract does not mention?

OECD analysis · Look beyond the contract
A written contract is the starting point, but this one does not address an economically relevant feature of the relationship (¶1.42–1.43). What Company S actually did points to a possible conclusion: the written contract may not capture everything in the commercial or financial relations of the two companies. So the analysis should not stop at the recorded terms. More evidence of the parties' conduct is needed, including the basis on which Company S took on the campaign. The example ends there: it does not say how the campaign should be treated or rewarded.
Key takeaway
A written contract is where the delineation of a transaction starts, not where it ends. Where the contract does not address something economically relevant, evidence of what the parties actually do supplements it.

Related: Section D.1.1 (the contractual terms of the transaction) · ¶1.42–1.43 (the contract as starting point, supplemented by evidence of conduct) · ¶1.48 (the next example: conduct that differs from the contract)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →