Group synergies
Example 19 — Central purchasing: Company A only negotiates
Chapter I · Example 4 (synergies) · ¶1.189 · Company A · group members
OECD Guidelines 2022At a glance
Company A is its group's central purchasing manager and, relying on the purchasing power of the entire group, negotiates a discount on widgets with an independent supplier. It does not buy and resell the widgets: having negotiated for the group, it leaves the members to buy from the supplier directly. Who keeps the benefit of the discount?
The parties
Company A
Central purchasing manager · negotiates the discountco-ordinating services
Group members
Buy the widgets directly from the independent supplierCompany A never takes title to the widgets and holds no inventory.
What happens
- Company A is given the role of central purchasing manager for the group as a whole.
- Using only the purchasing power of the entire group, it negotiates a supplier's price for widgets down from USD 200 to USD 110 (facts taken over from ¶1.188).
- Unlike in ¶1.188, Company A does not buy and resell the widgets. It negotiates the discount for the group, after which the members buy the widgets directly from the independent supplier.
- For these co-ordinating services the comparability analysis is assumed to suggest a fee of USD 5 per widget, against USD 6 per widget where Company A buys and resells (¶1.188).
Analysis
Company A negotiates the discount for the group; the members then buy the widgets from the independent supplier themselves. For Company A's co-ordinating services, the comparability analysis is assumed to suggest a fee of USD 5 per widget.
Who keeps the benefit of the group purchasing discount?
OECD analysis · Members keep discount after fee
Company A performed co-ordinating services for the other group members, and on the assumed comparability analysis its entitlement is a service fee of USD 5 per widget, even though it never buys or resells a widget. Once that fee is paid, the benefit of the group purchasing discount stays with the members that buy the widgets, each for the part attributable to its own purchases. The fee is assumed to be lower than the USD 6 of the buy-and-resell example (¶1.188), which may reflect the lower risk of a service provider that takes no title to the widgets and holds no inventory.
Key takeaway
Where a discount rests on the group's purchasing power, the company that negotiates it earns a fee for its co-ordinating services, whether or not it also buys and resells, and the purchasing members keep the rest. Taking no title and holding no inventory may mean less risk and a lower fee.
Related: ¶1.188 (Example 3: Company A buys and resells) · ¶1.180 (concerted action without purchase and sale transactions among group members) · Section D.8 (MNE group synergies)