Example 20 — A group volume discount invoiced to one affiliate
Chapter I · Example 5 (synergies) · ¶1.190–1.193 · MNE group based in Country A
OECD Guidelines 2022The parties
A purchasing employee at the group's shared services centre in Country D arranges the purchase and the invoicing. Other group members pay for the centre's services at cost plus, which the example assumes to be arm's-length compensation.
What happens
- A multinational group has its base in Country A, manufacturing subsidiaries in Country B (tax rate 30%) and Country C (tax rate 10%), and a shared services centre in Country D.
- Other group members, including the two manufacturing subsidiaries, pay the shared services centre on a cost plus basis, which is assumed to be arm's-length compensation for its services.
- Each manufacturing subsidiary needs 5 000 widgets from an independent supplier, which sells them at USD 10 apiece and gives a 5% discount on bulk purchases above 7 500 units.
- A purchasing employee at the centre confirms with the supplier that if both affiliates buy 5 000 widgets at the same time, the discount applies to all 10 000: a total price of USD 95 000.
- The employee places the orders and asks the supplier to invoice the Country B affiliate USD 50 000 and the Country C affiliate USD 45 000, each for 5 000 widgets. As it still receives the agreed USD 95 000, the supplier does so.
Analysis
Each affiliate takes 5 000 of the 10 000 widgets that together earn the 5% discount. The Country B affiliate is invoiced USD 50 000, what it would have paid buying alone, and the Country C affiliate USD 45 000. No explicit transaction links the two.
May Country B adjust the expenses of its manufacturing affiliate?
Related: Section D.8 (MNE group synergies) · ¶1.179, footnote 3 (deliberate concerted action requires arm's-length compensation) · ¶1.182 (purchasing synergies shared in proportion to purchase volumes)