Group synergies

Example 20 — A group volume discount invoiced to one affiliate

Chapter I · Example 5 (synergies) · ¶1.190–1.193 · MNE group based in Country A

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Manufacturing affiliates in Country B (tax rate 30%) and Country C (10%) each need 5 000 widgets. A purchasing employee at the shared services centre in Country D arranges simultaneous orders that earn a 5% bulk discount, then has the supplier invoice the Country B affiliate USD 50 000 and the Country C affiliate USD 45 000. May Country B adjust?
Independent supplier
USD 10 per widget · 5% discount on bulk purchases above 7 500 units
10 000 widgets for USD 95 000
Country B manufacturing affiliate
Country B tax rate 30% · 5 000 widgets · invoiced USD 50 000
Country C manufacturing affiliate
Country C tax rate 10% · 5 000 widgets · invoiced USD 45 000

A purchasing employee at the group's shared services centre in Country D arranges the purchase and the invoicing. Other group members pay for the centre's services at cost plus, which the example assumes to be arm's-length compensation.

  1. A multinational group has its base in Country A, manufacturing subsidiaries in Country B (tax rate 30%) and Country C (tax rate 10%), and a shared services centre in Country D.
  2. Other group members, including the two manufacturing subsidiaries, pay the shared services centre on a cost plus basis, which is assumed to be arm's-length compensation for its services.
  3. Each manufacturing subsidiary needs 5 000 widgets from an independent supplier, which sells them at USD 10 apiece and gives a 5% discount on bulk purchases above 7 500 units.
  4. A purchasing employee at the centre confirms with the supplier that if both affiliates buy 5 000 widgets at the same time, the discount applies to all 10 000: a total price of USD 95 000.
  5. The employee places the orders and asks the supplier to invoice the Country B affiliate USD 50 000 and the Country C affiliate USD 45 000, each for 5 000 widgets. As it still receives the agreed USD 95 000, the supplier does so.

Each affiliate takes 5 000 of the 10 000 widgets that together earn the 5% discount. The Country B affiliate is invoiced USD 50 000, what it would have paid buying alone, and the Country C affiliate USD 45 000. No explicit transaction links the two.

May Country B adjust the expenses of its manufacturing affiliate?

OECD analysis · Adjustment of USD 2 500
Country B would be entitled to a transfer pricing adjustment that lowers its manufacturing affiliate's expenses by USD 2 500. The Guidelines state the figure without the working: it equals the 5% discount on the affiliate's own 5 000 widgets at USD 10 apiece, which is half of the total discount. The way the invoices were split puts the benefit of the volume-purchasing synergy in the wrong place. That the Country B affiliate, acting alone, could not have bought for less than USD 50 000 does not stand in the way. Nor does the absence of an explicit transaction between the two manufacturing affiliates: the discount was arranged by deliberate concerted group action, which provides a basis for allocating part of it to the Country B affiliate.
Key takeaway
When a deliberate concerted group action earns a volume discount, the way the supplier is asked to split the invoices does not settle who gets the benefit. Part of it may be allocated to an affiliate that paid no more than it would have paid alone, even without an explicit transaction between the affiliates.

Related: Section D.8 (MNE group synergies) · ¶1.179, footnote 3 (deliberate concerted action requires arm's-length compensation) · ¶1.182 (purchasing synergies shared in proportion to purchase volumes)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →