Group synergies

Example 18 — Central purchasing: Company A buys and resells

Chapter I · Example 3 (synergies) · ¶1.188 · Company A · group members

OECD Guidelines 2022
At a glance
Company A acts as central purchasing manager for its whole group, buying from independent suppliers and reselling to its associated enterprises. Using only the purchasing power of the entire group, it negotiates a supplier's price for widgets down from USD 200 to USD 110. At what price should it resell the widgets to the other group members?
Independent supplier
Sells widgets · price reduced from USD 200 to USD 110
widgets at USD 110
Company A
Central purchasing manager · buys and resells
resale price?
Group members
Associated enterprises · buy from Company A
  1. Company A is given the role of central purchasing manager for the group as a whole.
  2. Company A buys from independent suppliers and sells on to its associated enterprises.
  3. Using only the negotiating leverage that comes from the purchasing power of the entire group, Company A gets a supplier to cut its widget price from USD 200 to USD 110.
  4. Comparable co-ordination services, in comparable uncontrolled transactions with a comparable volume of purchases, are assumed to have earned a service fee equal to USD 6 per widget in total.

The cut from USD 200 to USD 110 was won solely with the purchasing power of the entire group. Comparable co-ordination services are assumed to earn a fee of USD 6 per widget in total, set as Company A's costs plus a mark-up.

What is the arm's-length price for Company A's resale of the widgets to group members?

OECD analysis · Resale at about USD 116
The reduction was obtained solely on the strength of the entire group's purchasing power, so the arm's-length resale price would not be at or anywhere near the undiscounted USD 200. It would instead reward Company A for its services in co-ordinating the purchasing. On the assumed benchmark of USD 6 per widget, the intercompany resale price comes out at approximately USD 116. Each group member then derives approximately USD 84 per widget of benefit from the group's purchasing power, and Company A earns USD 6 per widget bought by the members for its service functions.
Key takeaway
Where a central purchasing company obtains a price reduction solely through the group's purchasing power, it is rewarded for its co-ordination services and does not keep the reduction. What remains of the purchasing synergy should typically be shared by group members in proportion to their purchase volumes (¶1.182).

Related: Section D.8 (MNE group synergies) · ¶1.180–1.182 (deliberate concerted action and how its benefits are shared) · ¶1.189 (Example 4: Company A negotiates but does not buy)

Test yourself on this example.Open it in the interactive walkthrough →